PLayer 1: 46 WE

Athleticism	41	Low		Perimeter	12	High
Speed	25	High		Ball Handling	31	High
Rebounding	29	High		Passing	15	High
Defense	25	High		Stamina	61	High
Shot Blocking	20	High		Durability	56	High
Low-post	23	High		FT Shooting		Average

Player 2: 73 WE

Athleticism	26	High		Perimeter	24	High
Speed	51	High		Ball Handling	48	Average
Rebounding	12	High		Passing	59	Average
Defense	19	High		Stamina	70	Average
Shot Blocking	5	Low		Durability	34	Low
Low-post	9	Low		FT Shooting		High

The guy will probably get a RS and be my project player to become a force by his JR* year. 

player 2

what position?

I think player 2 is gonna be much better offensively due to the high ath/ high spd, giving him 60at/75-80spd once maxed out, am I correct?

#1 is SF, #2 is SG, but these guys will probably play backup sg/sf for 2 years, then play starting SG. 

I'd prob go with #1 to be honest

If I had to choose, I would take Player 2. With a 73 WE he will progress very quickly towards his peak. With a redshirt and an extra season he will probably be pretty close to achieving his ceiling with most of those categories. He could also be nicely interchangeable at SF by his rs soph/rs junior year as well. As a matter of fact, by then, that is probably where I would end up sticking him since his PER would be a little low for a SG.

I went with #2 but it looks like he won't get the RS. I didn't realize my other SG/PG only has 24 WE, and probably need the additional year to reach close to his ceiling:

Athleticism	71	Low		Perimeter	41	High
Speed	43	High		Ball Handling	36	High
Rebounding	11	High		Passing	43	High
Defense	58	Average		Stamina	74	High
Shot Blocking	1	Low		Durability	27	High
Low-post	9	Low		FT Shooting		High

I think his ceiling is nuts, given he can reach 75 ath, 75-80 spd, along with 70+ per/bh/passing. Ofc, 24 WE makes reaching this ceiling impossible but I think he needs the RS more.

Do you actually know those categories you mention are high/high?  'Cause 75-80 speed means you're counting on 30+ improvement...  Same with pretty much everything else you mention.

Posted by dahsdebater on 10/23/2010 2:36:00 PM (view original):
Do you actually know those categories you mention are high/high?  'Cause 75-80 speed means you're counting on 30+ improvement...  Same with pretty much everything else you mention.

yep, did scouting reports on them as well.

Nice.  Too bad that WE isn't better, then...  That guy is a potential beast.

player 2 by a mile! this isn't even close. ath & spd ratings are gold! having high potential in both categories is gold!

Posted by uglyskunk3 on 10/23/2010 8:40:00 PM (view original):
player 2 by a mile! this isn't even close. ath & spd ratings are gold! having high potential in both categories is gold!

Good to get confirmation from a coach with a D3 dynasty!

And player 2's speed is high high via scouting report as well, so he could be nuts with 80-90 spd.