I'm a big fan of recruiting ineligibles and have never had two show up at the same time. I can't remember exactly when, but I seem to recall one coach, one time, saying that he actually had two show up in the same class, but I've never heard anyone else have it happen.
By the way, in the developer chat yesterday, Seble stated that the more effort that is put into recruiting an ineligible, the more it increases the chances that he signs. I'm not so sure that I totally agree with this, simply because in the last three seasons, I've done the $130 special (call, start, minutes, schollie) with three foreign kids and got all three of them to show up. Not much effort involved there......I don't know maybe I just got lucky. But three times in a row?