So this is a totally impossible question.  Why?  Because the two players in question don't even play in the same world.  Anyway, I was just wondering which of these power forwards people would take in an individual matchup.  I'm primarily thinking in a vacuum, although it's worth noting that both players do play alongside athletic centers with good rebounding and LP skills.  I think that works in my guy's favor.  Also, please don't think I'm arguing that either is the best PF in their world's D3.  They're just both very good PFs, and narcotico's is part of the greatest D3 dynasty in the new engine.

My guy: Donald Petit

His guy: Jeffrey Smith

(I'm just looking at the ratings, not their stats.) It's really close - both are awesome players - but I'd slightly favor narcotico's. You've got more ATH and better FT shooting, but his advantages in REB and LP are pretty significant. I also love his 12-pt advantage in stamina. My only concern about his is that the DEF rating isn't fantastic for M2M. I'm nitpicking, I know.

Yeah, it had actually occurred to me that we might both be better off if we swapped.  Probably not, though, since the rest of my team is pretty darn weak defensively and Petit helps a little.  I've never had a post defender of anything close to his caliber before.

first guy

Jeffrey Smith.