I would think that you would take the contrarian view of players. If your in a park like portland and you are deciding between 2 guys, one leaning to off the other to def, I would take the off guy. For 81 games your park will help him, and his off might make up for any def liabilities on the road. Conversely, if your in say hartford, I would focus more on guys who have slightly better D, for the opposit reason. You might have an offensive juggernaught at home, but can't field and catch away.