My alma mater, Georgetown (KY) is considering such a move for an unusual reason.. From the local newspaper:
Georgetown College is exploring a potential move for its athletics programs from the NAIA to the National Collegiate Athletic Association in its pursuit of Phi Beta Kappa status.
On April 13, the college sent a letter of membership interest to the NCAA Division III. If the college makes the move, it would no longer be able to offer athletics scholarships.
In 1996, a year after the trustees initially decided to pursue Phi Beta Kappa, a consultant advised them that the college, a member of the National Association of Intercollegiate Athletics, needed to pursue another athletic affiliation.
Many of the decisions and projects the college has taken on since the mid-1990s have been shaped by the trustees’ commitment to seeking Phi Beta Kappa status, said President Crouch.
The college has invested in a new library facility and now employs more faculty members who are graduates of Phi Beta Kappa institutions. It has improved its liberal arts curriculum, attracted a more diverse student population, and changed its working relationship with the Kentucky Baptist Convention.
Crouch said no decisions have been made by trustees to join a new athletic association or stick with the current NAIA membership in the Mid-South Conference.
Phi Beta Kappa does not require schools to be in any certain athletic associations. But none of the 290 NAIA colleges and universities has a Phi Beta Kappa chapter.
Crouch said NCAA Division III is perceived to be a more academically-based athletic program than the NAIA.
NCAA membership would bring many benefits to the college, such as the increased academic commitment, the reimbursement of travel expenses, and the additional marketing the college would receive, Crouch said.
“CNN runs the names and outcomes for football games on Saturday for all NCAA games,” said Crouch. “They do not do NAIA schools. An 18-year-old sitting in their dining room could see Georgetown College, Ky., across the bottom of their screen. They don’t see that now.”
The Tigers’ men’s basketball team made it to the NAIA final four this season, but staying in the association would take a continual financial commitment, said Crouch.