I don't normally do this, but I'm torn on tonight's draft and thought I'd get some quick opinions from folks!  My draft budgets are 20/20.

Here are two pitchers:

Bats	Throws	Age	Durability	Stamina	Control	Left Pitch	Right Pitch	Velocity	Groundball	1st	2nd	3rd	4th	5th	Makeup	Temper	Patience	Speed	Health	Durability
R	R	18	27	74	96	86	89	85	46	79	80	72	42	0	61	54	99	47	77	27
S	R	18	26	72	85	82	87	93	53	93	60	60	43	0	79	46	27	26	98	26

And one hitter:

Bats	Throws	Age	Contact	Power	Left Hit	Right Hit	Eye	Speed	Baserunning	Range	Glove	PitchCall	Makeup	Durability	Health	Patience	Temper	Bunt	PushPull	Hitters Only	ArmStrength	ArmAccuracy
R	R	18	80	72	85	81	72	79	73	80	88	6	82	82	88	62	100	13	11	390	82	86

Normally I would take a pitcher over a hitter, so I'm leaning towards that.  And the top pitcher looks better to me, except I'm concerned with his makeup being 18 points lower that he may not develop as good.  I think the pitches are a toss-up, with the 93 P1 vs the other guy's 3 strong pitches (despite not having an elite pitch).  All that said, the hitter is attractive as well, since he could play SS and be an elite hitter with very good speed.

So who would you take?  Pitcher 1, Pitcher 2, or the Hitter?

Also since it didn't format perfectly, the pitchers have Health of 77 for Pitcher 1 and 98 for pitcher 2.  Pitcher 1 will sign in the 1st round, pitcher 2 for slot.

The hitter's arm strength is 82 and accuracy is 86.  He will only sign if the deal is right.

The hitter will not be a SS.   AS and range will definitely fall short.