20+ better ATH should almost always win. I would take a guy with 70 Ath, 60 Reb, and 45 LP over a guy with 45 Ath, 75 Reb, and 75 LP, for example. On the other hand, if you give the 2nd guy 100 reb, 90+ LP, and very good DEF, SB, and BH, maybe he's got a shot. But you get the point.