You have 4 states scouted that, I presume, are very close to your campus. If so, my advice is to just...wait.
Let signings start and see who is left over and not considering anyone once kids have started to sign their life on the dotted line. Then go and find ONE player with good potentials/starting values in the core categories for his position. Preferably, this will be a player within 200 miles of you. I realize you need to fill 2 scholarships, but I recommend you stagger your approach. The situation you want to avoid at all costs is taking two walk-ons. One is okay. Wait for the initial dust of signings to settle and then see what's left over. Stay close to home to keep costs down...you might not get a home run recruit, but you can find plenty of very solid recruits after signings start, especially in high-expense states to scout like NY. Once you have the first guy signed, then you can repeat the process with whatever cash you have left to try and get a second. If you offer a kid a scholarship and he considers you, but doesn't sign, think about promising him 10 minutes...that's an easy promise to meet for most coaches and at 10 bucks is a nice cheap persuasive offer to a kid that needs a nudge.