How do 68 Gibson and 65 Koufax do at Petco in a high cap? They seem to get lit up anywhere that doesn't suppress HR. Still, in a high cap there wil be some big guns in the lineups. With thier high Ks will they perform better than 08 Joss, 13 Johnson, 15 Alexander, 08 Brown etc in Petco?

I think Gibson and Koufax get lit up wherever they pitch in high cap, especially at 255 and especially Gibson, although they get beat up less in parks like Petco.  Nobody performs better as starters than Joss `08, Alexander `15, Maddux `95, Martinez `00, Johnson `13 and Mathewson `09... certainly not Gibson and Koufax.

What he said.

Take 95 Greg, 00 Pedro and Joss.  Forget about Koufax and Gibson.  They'll kill you in a high cap, even at Petco.

I completely understand that MLB is MLB & WIS is WIS & I agree with the opinion of Joss, Pedro, Maddux, Pete & Matty being better than Koufax & Gibby in higher caps but when you look at the data-OAV+, WHIP+, ERA+, HR/9 I don't see the reason that should happen.

I am about to use Joss, Pedro, Maddux, Matty in a 255 league (no player >$15mm) at Clevelands League park but I chose Joss & Matty because of WIS perfomance history not because of the data that I am looking at.