(TIE) -
My first season at Redlands (D3, Naismith). I had one other team, W Conn State in Allen, didn't know what I was doing and signed a guard with 1 sp (the FAQ told me I should be emphasizing bh and pa!) Redlands was my do-over, if that had gone poorly, who knows if I would've even kept playing. I inherited a very strong team, signed a highly-ranked class and made the S16, and that was the beginning ...
Tark, Western Michigan, Season 10-ish. This was just before the elites were human occupied. We had an awesome group of coaches in the MAC. I knew as soon as I signed my first class there that they would be awesome (remember, we were taking studs away from sim BCS programs). Ended up winning the NT with WMU, which obviously is diluted due to lack of competition, but it was still a ton of fun with a stacked team running press and having the MAC dominate. Just a fun season with players I liked.