Regardless of team need (my team  needs everything) which one would you take:

	Current Rating	Potential			Current Rating	Potential
Athleticism	62	Low		Perimeter	53	High
Speed	56	High		Ball Handling	59	High
Rebounding	8	Low		Passing	35	High
Defense	49	High		Stamina	61	High
Shot Blocking	15	Average		Durability	49	Low
Low-post	12	High		FT Shooting		High

def/per/bh/p are high high, spd is low high.

Or this big:

	Current Rating	Potential			Current Rating	Potential
Athleticism	55	High		Perimeter	20	Average
Speed	11	Average		Ball Handling	26	Average
Rebounding	73	High		Passing	32	High
Defense	48	High		Stamina	73	Average
Shot Blocking	68	High		Durability	73	Low
Low-post	35	Low		FT Shooting		Low

The guard looks pretty with those highs but I think the Big is a much better player. Thoughts?

i like the guard best.  

I would take the guard

For those saying the guard, please be aware that this is D1. The guard will have matchup problems against most of the BCS backcourt players, while the C probably won't with 80ath/90s in reb/sb. 

With the new information I would change to the C, although not a huge fan of the low LP. I am not in D1 though, so my opinion doesn't matter much.

I think the guard is a better player, but it seems that recently there have been a greater abundance of serviceable to good guards than big men.  I'm fairly certain this applies to lower D1 as well, though I only peruse those players in a cursory fashion most of the time.  I'd probably take the center because you might not find one like him next recruiting cycle that you can get your hands on, whereas your probability of finding a similar guard is very good.