This is for D3. I run a press defense.

Player 1: 30 WE

Athleticism	22	Low		Perimeter	43	Average
Speed	61	High		Ball Handling	52	High
Rebounding	15	Average		Passing	49	High
Defense	26	Average		Stamina	68	High
Shot Blocking	8	Low		Durability	25	High
Low-post	14	Low		FT Shooting		Average

Player 2: 45 WE

Athleticism	39	High		Perimeter	63	Low
Speed	58	Low		Ball Handling	60	High
Rebounding	13	Low		Passing	34	High
Defense	40	High		Stamina	67	Average
Shot Blocking	1	Low		Durability	71	High
Low-post	1	Low		FT Shooting		High

I guess what I see in Player 1 is exceptional core ratings for a D3 PG (80 SPD, 70 PASS/BH at the very least) but poor ATH/DEF that will make him a liability in the press. Player 2 will excell in the press, but his passing won't be as good and he's not nearly as fast as Player 1.

Which would you prefer? Thanks in advance

#2 is better. The def is going to be huge. 

Player 2 - Def, Per, FT