Go with 12 pitchers, 13 position players.
Pitchers = 5 starters, Long A, Long B (sho can be pretty cruddy), 2 or three Set-Up A's (depending on ho many nice relievers you have) and 2 or three Set-Up B's
Position Players = 8 positional starters. Back up catcher, corner OF, back-up 3B, back-up SS, back-up 2B/CF. Or something close.