TBH, your big looks pretty solid, and the Guard doesn't (ATH and DEF are too weak). Athtleticism and defense are probably the most important attributes in the game (of course other ratings like the ones you mentioned matter too, but try to focus on those first). I reccomend looking at the top teams at D3 in Phelan, and seeing what ratings their players have and trying to get as close to those as possible (after potential, you find potential using FSS, or future stars scouting during recruiting.) If you're committed to becoming a good coach I strongly reccomend you read this thread: http://whatifsports.com/forums/Posts.aspx?TopicID=453763&Page=1 GL and sitemail me if you have any questions.