Two recruits, one spot. 9 hours to make the call. Either would fit


SG- 3 star top 20 guy,

ATH 58 Average
SPD 64 Average
REB 1 Low
DEF 58 High/High
SB 1 Low
LP 51 Low
PER 71 Low
BH 77 Low
Pass 59 Low
WE 49
Stam 60 High/High

SF- Ranked between 70 and 80 and will accept redshirt

ATH 73 Low
Spd 40 High
Reb 43 Low
Def 67 Average
SB 28 Low
LP 71 High/High
Per 11 High/High
BH 24 High/High
Pass 27 Low
WE 48
Stam 77 Average


We have 2 Pg, 1 SG, 2 SF  (1 has started at SG for a season)

Any help would be appreciated. I lean toward the SF but sometime I let stars and rankings cloud my judgment when I shouldnt.

Which one of them enjoys long walks on the beach?

No, in all seriousness...

I'd probably take the second guy. I like the high high on the DEF for the first one, but you could probably get a lot out of the scoring potential of the second, especially with a redshirt to give him every chance to max out.

Then again, this assumes you're in a vacuum - what I'd do would be dependent upon the team I already have.

I like #2, and it's not that close for me. Not the biggest fan of #1 other than as a weak-scoring defensive specialist, and #2 will progress very well and be an excellent player. High LP in small forwards has always been a good recipe for success.