http://whatifsports.com/hd/PlayerProfile/Ratings.aspx?tid=0&pid=2539803


with highs still in def,lp,passing, avg speed, stamina
was a Juco recruit brought in to be backup point guard last year. while the nxt guy reshirted so iq's are the same..

http://whatifsports.com/hd/PlayerProfile/Ratings.aspx?tid=0&pid=2539804
highs in ath,speed, def,bh,st,avg in reb,lp,passing,ft

obv from a overall standpoint its the senior but not potential standpoint and who would be better at end of season ... thoughts comments concerns?

What defense are you running?  What are you practicing?  When I checked to figure out what systems you run, I saw some weird grades.   

Assuming you run Fastbreak & m2m (which you should be practicing to the exclusion of everything else), then both players are likely to get sufficient minutes to improve well.  Since there is no chance that the freshmen will complain about minutes, then that's the tiebreaker; start the senior.  Only if the senior were maxed out in core categories would I go the other way.

Yes run man to man, and fastbreak uptempo, both players will recieve about the same minutes but was curious to see who thought which player was better
practice both 20 mins standard