to me, the specific answer to a "who should I draft?" question normally starts and ends with "whoever you like". The more general explanation (from a pure baseball standpoint rather than a WIS standpoint) is a conceptual understanding of what positions/player type hierarchy you want to target. I base my hierarchy on scarcity and marginal advantage.
My pyramid is: #1- always start with having as much dominant starting pitching as possible, #2- gold glove+silver slugger 5-tool SS, #3 gold glove CF with power+speed, #4 gold glove 2B with power+speed, #5- dominant relief pitching, #6- toolsy on-base/power/defense/(+speed?) combination catcher, #6 strong-armed + plus-glove offensive 3B, #7 power-hitting 1B, #8 power-hitting RF with strong-arm, #9 power-hitting LF
Out of your 5 examples, none of them necessarily fit the bill for any of those prototypes, so the answer, for me, would revert to whoever comes the closest to my positional ideal; and because none of them suit my fancies I would just say to myself pick whoever you like because no matter what you probably won't be too happy