One of these three guys is going to get the call after 20 AAA games and get my MLB LF spot: Which guy would be the better offensive player, in your estimation:

http://whatifsports.com/HBD/Pages/Popups/PlayerProfile.aspx?pid=6437464

http://whatifsports.com/HBD/Pages/Popups/PlayerProfile.aspx?pid=6620164

http://whatifsports.com/HBD/Pages/Popups/PlayerProfile.aspx?pid=6784515

1st guy is Augie Tamura: RHB 21 years old Bat/62-80-61-64-48 Projects to/76-86-73-30-55 (This is his 4th season)

2nd guy is Theodore Anderson SH 22 years old Bat/23-93-50-47-42 Projects to/34-100-66-53-49 (This is his 3rd season)

2nd guy is David Cordero RHB 23 years old Bat/67-51-89-62-72 Projects to/78-56-100-66-74 (This is just his 2nd season. He was an IFA)

Not enough difference in the gloves to spit at (all will be better than decent LF'ers. Tamura's Durability is 75, Anderson's 86, Cordero's 88. Cordero is a better than average base runner, the other's aren't)

All can survive at the MLB level with their bats, but in different ways. Who do you pick?

Go with Cordero against LHP only. Find someone else to platoon with, but not the other two. That's what I'd do. If no platoon I'd go Cordero full time  IMO.

Posted by ramonshaw on 12/5/2014 5:56:00 PM (view original):
Go with Cordero against LHP only. Find someone else to platoon with, but not the other two. That's what I'd do. If no platoon I'd go Cordero full time  IMO.

+1, although Tamura is close.

Probably don't have the LHB LF'er to platoon with Cordero.  Otherwise it would be easy....

Anybody play a guy with a 63-40-63-57ish  glove in LF?