This resume:
Season Overall RPI SOS Notes
102 21-9 36 59 NT (1st Round)
101 23-7 44 95 NT (1st Round)
100 19-10 67 109 PI (1st Round)
99 20-11 90 110 NT (1st Round)
Was selected over this one:
Season Overall RPI SOS Notes
102 23-8 66 104 PI (2nd Round)
101 24-6 25 82 NT (2nd Round)
100 20-10 78 114 PI (2nd Round)
99 26-6 24 72 NT (Sweet Sixteen)
From this it seems to me that making the NT is more important than getting past the 1st round of the NT, can anyone see anything else that differentiates?