Both are very good, but I am with Strikeout on this one -- guy #1 is who I am taking. Although I think it is closer than some might think. That HUGE P1 to go with those splits is a nice combo on guy #2.. However, guy #1 will pitch more innings, has a better split against righties (HIUGE) and, from my experience, older Intl guys are often over projected (even with $20 in Intl scouting).