I've been playing around with the Dream Teams feature and decided to put together a team of go-to players. These are guys that you almost always include on every SIM team, and always perform well at any cap, and in any theme.

Let's see your favorite cookies. Will be interesting to see the diverse array of roster construction!
Pos Player Bats AVG HR RBI Field/Range Salary
C 2001 Paul Lo Duca R .320 25 90 B/A+ $6,127,875
1B 1993 John Olerud L .363 24 107 B-/C- $8,582,259
2B 1996 Eric Young R .324 8 74 B/A+ $6,651,694
3B 1998 Vinny Castilla R .319 46 144 A/C+ $7,120,262
SS 1987 Tony Fernandez S .322 5 67 A/A- $6,985,330
OF 1930 Babe Herman L .393 35 130 B/D $9,490,115
OF 1980 Willie Wilson S .326 3 49 B+/A+ $8,270,710
OF 1923 Harry Heilmann R .403 18 115 C-/C+ $9,886,067
OF 1995 Dante Bichette R .340 40 128 B/D- $6,337,343
C 1986 Ron Hassey L .353 3 20 B/B $2,131,417
1B 1980 Cecil Cooper L .352 25 122 A/A- $7,636,143
SS 2007 Jeff Keppinger R .332 5 32 A+/D- $2,462,719
OF 2010 Jarrod Dyson L .211 1 5 C/A+ $554,013
Role Player Throws W-L SV ERA WHIP K-BB Salary
SP 1906 Jack Pfiester L 20-8 0 1.51 0.94 153-63 $10,252,659
SP/RP 2002 Pedro Martinez R 20-4 0 2.26 0.92 239-40 $8,994,829
SP/RP 1964 Joe Horlen R 13-9 0 1.88 0.94 138-55 $8,931,684
SP/RP 1976 Mark Fidrych R 19-9 0 2.34 1.08 97-53 $7,189,617
SP/RP 1994 Steve Ontiveros R 6-4 0 2.65 1.03 56-26 $5,629,688
SP/RP 1986 Frank Williams R 3-1 1 1.20 1.07 33-21 $1,693,906
SP/RP 1989 Todd Burns R 6-5 8 2.24 0.98 49-28 $3,678,907
SP/RP 1987 Dave Smith R 2-3 24 1.65 1.00 73-21 $2,963,878
SP/RP 1988 John Franco L 6-6 39 1.57 1.01 46-27 $2,914,263
SP/RP 2001 Steve Karsay R 0-1 1 1.25 0.85 44-8 $2,289,710
SP/RP 1981 Andy Rincon R 3-1 0 1.77 0.90 13-5 $2,145,127
SP/RP 1992 Dennis Rasmussen L 4-1 0 1.43 0.82 12-6 $2,011,353
11/3/2020 8:18 PM (edited)
93 Olerud for sure.
80 Wilson for sure
81 Rincon
I would not call him a cookie but 37 Medwick ALWAYS comes through...insane amount of doubles and average.
93 Tony Phillips.
53 Ted Williams. Only 107 ABs and pricey but the dude WILL deliver 8-10 Wins guaranteed with PH Hrs. and a spot start. So much better than traditional cookies (Cedeno, Spencer, Loretta, Waner, etc.)
2003 Gagne. Money.
2009 Mike Adams. Closer.
11/4/2020 4:28 PM
I might have to replace Tony Fernandez with 2001 Rich Aurilia!
2/23/2021 1:52 AM

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2026 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.