Round 3 - Winning % by Teams Selected Topic

schwarze
Posts: 44817 (1)
Hall of Famer
1845 74 4 1 1
Hall of Famer
Just for fun, I calculated the cumulative winning percentage of the 240 rosters drafted. I left the sort order based on the draft order, within each division. I know team winning% does not necessarily correlate to the best roster construction, but I found it interesting anyway.
.
Owner Div# Pick# Team Name - League 1 Win%
--------------------- -------- -------- -------------------------------------------- --------
PEDROCERRANO 1 1 1903 Naps/1903 Tigers/1902 Americans 0.530
MLLAMA54 2 7 02 Athletics/02 Reds/04 Pirates 0.560
SCHWARZE 3 8 1902 Blues (03 PIT - 04 CHI) 0.588
GLOWGUY 4 14 1902 Pirates 1904 Giants 1904 Naps 0.668
.
BARRACUDA3 1 2 1906 Cubs 1906 Browns 1905 Reds 0.597
OLDTIMER59 2 16 05NYG 05CHC 04PITT 0.619
CALHOOP 3 19 04 NYG - 04 CUBS - 06 CLEV 0.627
KSTOBER 4 22 04 Naps, 05 Pirates, 06 White Sox 0.604
.
SCHWARZE 1 4 1906 Cubs (06 STL - 08 PIT) 0.637
BEALLENDALL 2 15 1908 NYG - 1908 BOS - 1908 DET 0.571
YBJSPORTS 3 17 1907 Pittsburgh 0.605
JOERAT1 4 21 06 Pirates 07 Cubs 08 White Sox 0.630
.
NOCOMM999 1 5 '08 Naps/'09 A's/'10 Tigers 0.588
KSTOBER 2 9 09 Pirates, 09 Tigers, 08 Cubs 0.670
SCHWARZE 3 13 1909 Cubs (08 PIT - 08 DET) 0.635
PEDROCERRANO 4 23 1908 Giants/1910 A's/1910 Red Sox 0.615
.
REDCPED 1 6 1912 Red Sox/1912 Giants/1912 Pirates 0.663
FOOTBALLMM11 2 11 12 PHA / 11 DET / 12 WSN 0.590
CHISOCK 3 12 1911 PIT/1910 BOS/1911 PHA 0.583
THEJUICE6 4 20 10PHA 10CHC 11NYG 0.667
.
D_ROCK97 1 3 1912 CHC, 1913 NYG, 1914 BOS 0.622
TOYSBOYS 2 10 1914 CHI / 1913 PHA / 1914 PHI 0.558
BIG_DOWG 3 18 '12 Athletics/12 Pirates/'14 Senators 0.578
DARTHDURRON 4 24 1912 BOS/1912 NYG/1912 DET 0.608
.
.
Owner Div# Pick# Team Name - League 2 Win%
--------------------- -------- -------- -------------------------------------------- --------
TOYSBOYS 1 1 1914 CHI / 1914 PHI / 1914 PHA 0.566
SCHWARZE 2 2 1914 Red Sox (15 STL - 15 IND) 0.578
RONTHEGENIUS 3 6 1915 Phillies / 15 White Sox / 16 Giants 0.587
KSTOBER 4 15 16 White Sox, 15 Tigers, 16 Reds 0.540
.
EMANES10 1 3 1916 CWS / 1916 DET / 1917 STL 0.561
GLOWGUY 2 12 1916 Robins 1917 White Sox 1918 Cubs 0.637
BILL_JAMES47 3 21 Giant Reds in Washington 0.555
NJBIGWIG 4 24 Bigwig's LG02 - CLE/NYG/DET 0.573
.
THEJUICE6 1 5 19NYG 19CIN 20NYY 0.641
PEDROCERRANO 2 9 1920 Indians/1920 White Sox/1919 Pirates 0.590
CHISOCK 3 14 1919 CHW/1918 NYG/1920 STB 0.566
SCHWARZE 4 16 1918 Cubs (18 WAS - 20 STL) 0.567
.
EJSTOCKMAN 1 4 1920 Reds Indians White Sox 0.599
BODDICKER 2 10 20 PIT/ 21 NYY/ 22 STL 0.568
REDCPED 3 17 1922 Browns/1920 Giants/1921 Cardinals 0.577
URBAND 4 22 20 NYY.21 Indians Giants 0.605
.
BARRACUDA3 1 7 1924 Robins 1922 Browns 1924 Cardinals 0.541
SCHWARZE 2 8 1924 Senators (24 CIN - 24 NYG) 0.583
FOOTBALLMM11 3 13 23 NYY / 23 CIN / 23 CLE 0.591
JTPSOPS 4 23 Hollocher?? I hardly know her! 0.576
.
TOYSBOYS 1 11 1925 CIN / 1925 STL / 1925 PIT 0.549
MLLAMA54 2 18 24 Robins/25 Athletics/26 Athletics 0.577
BEALLENDALL 3 19 1924 WAS - 1925 BKN - 1926 CHC 0.525
CALHOOP 4 20 24 PGH - 24 CIN - 24 CLE 0.523
.
.
Owner Div# Pick# Team Name - League 3 Win%
--------------------- -------- -------- -------------------------------------------- --------
BARRACUDA3 1 1 1927 Yankees 1928 Athletics 1928 Pirates 0.638
STEVEIZZY 2 15 26PHA\27NYG\28NYY 0.602
JOERAT1 3 19 26 Yankees 26 Cardinals 28 Senators 0.552
PUBDOG 4 24 1927 Cards Pirates Sens 0.588
.
D_ROCK97 1 6 1928 CHC, 1928 NYG, 1930 PHI 0.619
GLOWGUY 2 14 1928 Yankees 1928 Athletics 1930 Cubs 0.627
SCHWARZE 3 16 1930 Robins (28 WAS - 29 PHI) 0.580
THE_CREEPER 4 21 Yankees & Pirates & Robins...Oh My 0.540
.
CALHOOP 1 2 30 WASH - 31 A's - 32 NYY 0.670
FOOTBALLMM11 2 7 30 NYY / 32 CIN / 32 PHA 0.519
PEDROCERRANO 3 12 1931 Giants/1930 Robins/1930 Cubs 0.572
URBAND 4 13 31 NYY.30 Giants A's 0.614
.
NOCOMM999 1 4 3 from '33 0.590
SCHWARZE 2 5 1934 Yankees (32 CIN - 34 STL) 0.540
KSTOBER 3 8 32 Yankees, 34 Tigers, 32 Pirates 0.636
FOOTBALLMM11 4 22 32 PHA / 34 NYG / 34 PIT 0.571
.
DARTHDURRON 1 9 1934 NYG/1935 DET/1935 STLC 0.616
TOYSBOYS 2 10 1934 NYY / 1936 PIT / 1934 DET 0.604
NORDAWG 3 11 21st Street Missionaries 0.603
THEJUICE6 4 17 34SLC 35NYG 36NYY 0.627
.
BARRACUDA3 1 3 1937 Yankees 1937 Tigers 1937 Bees 0.587
BILL_JAMES47 2 18 Earl and Arky"s Ugly Dogs 0.554
CHISOCK 3 20 1936 NYY/1938 NYG/1938 CIN 0.589
PARKING31 4 23 the other Bill Lee (Big Bill Lee) 0.600
.
.
Owner Div# Pick# Team Name - League 4 Win%
--------------------- -------- -------- -------------------------------------------- --------
BARRACUDA3 1 1 1939 Yankees 1939 Cardinals 1940 Indians 0.627
FOOTBALLMM11 2 21 39 CIN / 40 DET / 40 BOS 0.582
TOYSBOYS 3 22 1940 CIN / 1940 NYY / 1938 BOS 0.605
CHISOCK 4 23 1940 BRK/1939 BOS/1938 NYG 0.573
.
EMANES10 1 9 1941 BRO / 1940 BOS / 1940 CWS 0.571
DARTHDURRON 2 14 1942 STLC/ 1942 NYY/1940 PITT 0.621
URBAND 3 15 41 NYY.Reds.Red Sox 0.591
D_ROCK97 4 16 1940 CIN, 1940 NYY, 1942 BOS 0.612
.
SCHWARZE 1 6 1944 Cardinals (44 BOS - 44 CLE) 0.550
CALHOOP 2 8 43 NYY - 43 BKLN - 44 CIN 0.581
REDCPED 3 17 1943 Cardinals/1942 Yankees/1942 Giants 0.637
JTPSOPS 4 18 Tuesdays with Morty 0.581
.
TOYSBOYS 1 5 1944 STL / 1946 DET / 1944 BOS 0.593
OLDTIMER59 2 7 46NYY 44NYY 44CLE 0.524
BARRACUDA3 3 10 1946 Red Sox 1945 Cubs 1945 Senators 0.626
KSTOBER 4 11 44 Reds, 46 Cardinals, 45 Tigers 0.594
.
SCHWARZE 1 2 1948 Indians (46 NYY - 46 DET) 0.596
GLOWGUY 2 19 46 Red Sox 47 Yankees 47Braves 0.621
WINTERHAWK 3 20 46STL/47NYG/48NYY 0.588
PMARS2001 4 24 1948 Bosox/Cards/Braves 0.589
.
FOOTBALLMM11 1 3 48 CLE / 50 NYY / 50 STL 0.591
PEDROCERRANO 2 4 1949 Red Sox/1949 Cardinals/1948 Braves 0.614
NORDAWG 3 12 Truman's Buckstoppers 0.587
THEJUICE6 4 13 49BRK 49CLE 50NYG 0.589
.
.
Owner Div# Pick# Team Name - League 5 Win%
--------------------- -------- -------- -------------------------------------------- --------
REDCPED 1 5 1951 Dodgers/1950 Giants/1952 Indians 0.593
NOCOMM999 2 10 '50 Red Sox/'52 Phillies/'52 Cubs 0.558
GLOWGUY 3 12 1951 Giants/1951 Phillies/1952 Yankees 0.572
CHISOCK 4 13 1952 STL/1952 BRK/1952 PHA 0.571
.
BARRACUDA3 1 2 1954 Indians 1952 Cardinals 1954 Dodgers 0.630
FOOTBALLMM11 2 9 53 BRK / 52 PHI / 53 STL 0.595
WINTERHAWK 3 14 54NYG/52CLE/54NYY 0.634
OLDTIMER59 4 23 54PHIL 53MIL 52BKN 0.571
.
KSTOBER 1 3 54 Indians, 55 Yankees, 55 Reds 0.610
SCHWARZE 2 7 1956 Yankees (56 CHI - 55 MIL) 0.578
TOYSBOYS 3 16 1956 CLE / 1955 BRK / 1954 CHW 0.607
BIGSTEVE12 4 21 54 & 56 Brooklyn Dodgers + 54 Phillies 0.563
.
TOYSBOYS 1 4 1956 BRK / 1958 MLW / 1958 NYY 0.600
PEDROCERRANO 2 8 1956 Yankees/1956 White Sox/1957 Braves 0.600
DARTHDURRON 3 11 1956 CLE/1957 CWS/1956 DET 0.563
JOERAT1 4 15 56 Braves 57 Dodgers 57 Yankees 0.593
.
KSTOBER 1 18 60 Yankees, 59 Cubs, 60 Braves 0.561
EMANES10 2 19 1958 MLW / 1960 CWS / 1959 SFG 0.567
JRIG21 3 20 58NYY, 59 CHISOX, 59 DET 0.567
THEJUICE6 4 24 59MIL 59BAL 60PIT 0.550
.
SCHWARZE 1 1 1961 Yankees (61 BAL - 62 LAD) 0.626
YBJSPORTS 2 6 1961 Detroit 0.597
URBAND 3 17 62 NYY.61 Reds.60 O's 0.591
SPINALDOG 4 22 60 CWS/62 MLW/62 CIN 0.567
.
.
Owner Div# Pick# Team Name - League 6 Win%
--------------------- -------- -------- -------------------------------------------- --------
BARRACUDA3 1 2 1964 White Sox 1964 Braves 1964 Giants 0.568
BEALLENDALL 2 8 1964 LAD - 1962 SFG - 1963 CWS 0.566
GLOWGUY 3 23 1963 Cardinals/1963 Dodgers/1964 Yankees 0.599
JRIG21 4 24 64 Orioles,63 Giants, 62 NYY 0.578
.
SCHWARZE 1 4 1964 White Sox (64 NYY - 64 MIL) 0.586
FOOTBALLMM11 2 6 66 SFG / 65 CIN / 65 LAD 0.575
KSTOBER 3 7 64 Orioles, 66 Dodgers, 66 Braves 0.570
CALHOOP 4 19 64 LAD - 64 PHIL - 65 SFG 0.549
.
TOYSBOYS 1 3 1966 SFG / 1968 DET / 1966 BAL 0.607
REDCPED 2 13 1967 White Sox/1966 Pirates/1967 Cards 0.582
DOUGSDAWGS13 3 16 66-68 Chief Cards 0.553
CHISOCK 4 17 1966 LAD/1968 BAL/1966 DET 0.564
.
PEDROCERRANO 1 1 1969 Orioles/1968 Cardinals/1970 Giants 0.601
TOYSBOYS 2 15 1969 NYM / 1968 DET / 1969 MIN 0.617
84CHAMPS 3 21 68Cle 70Bos 70Balt 0.579
FOOTBALLMM11 4 22 70 CIN / 69 LAD / 70 MIN 0.586
.
HARRELSON 1 5 70-72 Balt/LAD/SFG Heavy Horses 0.582
DARTHDURRON 2 9 1972 OAK/1970 MINN/1970 HOU 0.564
3DAYROTATION 3 10 .70 red sox, 72 reds & angels 0.546
THEJUICE6 4 18 70CIN 71BAL 71OAK 0.632
.
OLDTIMER59 1 11 72 CIN 73 BALT 74 ATL 0.586
STEVEIZZY 2 12 72OAK/73LAD/73ATL 0.554
SCHWARZE 3 14 1974 Reds (72 LAD - 72 CHI ) 0.567
KSTOBER 4 20 74 Athletics, 74 Dodgers, 73 Reds 0.599
.
.
Owner Div# Pick# Team Name - League 7 Win%
--------------------- -------- -------- -------------------------------------------- --------
GLOWGUY 1 2 1975 Reds/1975 Mets/1976 Phillies 0.599
BARRACUDA3 2 4 1975 Dodgers 1975 Red Sox 1974 Reds 0.581
FOOTBALLMM11 3 10 76 CIN / 74 PIT / 74 ATL 0.572
JOERAT1 4 23 74 Dodgers 76 Mets 76 Royals 0.572
.
SCHWARZE 1 5 1976 Reds (77 LAD - 77 NYM) 0.543
CHISOCK 2 7 1977 CIN/1978 PHI/1978 MIL 0.558
YBJSPORTS 3 14 1977 Minnesota 0.563
NOCOMM999 4 17 '76 Mets/'76 Royals/'78 Yankees 0.567
.
STEVEIZZY 1 8 79BOS/79HOU/80OAK 0.543
REDCPED 2 12 1978 Brewers/1980 Phillies/1979 Cards 0.556
SCHWARZE 3 16 1978 Yankees (80 LAD - 80 MIL) 0.570
OLDTIMER59 4 20 79BALT 80KC 78BOS 0.616
.
SCHWARZE 1 1 1981 Astros (81 CAL - 80 KCR) 0.539
PEDROCERRANO 2 13 1982 Brewers/1982 Expos/1981 Yankees 0.556
BILL_JAMES47 3 18 Fernandomania At The Vet 0.555
THEJUICE6 4 19 81MON 82SLC 82CAL 0.566
.
TOYSBOYS 1 9 1982 LAD / 1982 CAL / 1984 BAL 0.547
COACHGREAT1 2 21 Orioles/Tigers/Jays 1983/84 Bash 0.599
DARTHDURRON 3 22 1982 MON/`983 CWS/1983 DET 0.570
GLOWGUY 4 24 1982 Brewers/1982 Astros/ 1984 Cubs 0.553
.
BEALLENDALL 1 3 1985 STL - 1985 NYY - 1985 KCR 0.596
CALHOOP 2 6 84 BALT - 85 LAD - 86 BOS 0.567
KSTOBER 3 11 85 Mets, 85 Expos, 86 Blue Jays 0.553
84CHAMPS 4 15 84Tigers 86Mets 86Astros 0.634
.
.
Owner Div# Pick# Team Name - League 8 Win%
--------------------- -------- -------- -------------------------------------------- --------
SPINALDOG 1 1 86 HOU/87 STL/88 MIL under the Dome 0.572
CHISOCK 2 12 1988 CIN/1987 TOR/1987 SFG 0.563
KSTOBER 3 15 88 Mets, 88 Red Sox, 87 Tigers 0.593
BEALLENDALL 4 23 1986 BOS - 1988 LAD - 1986 TOR 0.568
.
TOYSBOYS 1 11 1990 OAK / 1988 BOS / 1990 CIN 0.582
REDCPED 2 14 1988 Reds/1989 Giants/1990 Blue Jays 0.546
RIBBENTROP 3 20 Athletics Royals Dodgers Stadium 0.588
FATBOYDAD54 4 21 3Rivers 80Bucs~88Mets~89Cards 0.581
.
SCHWARZE 1 4 1990 A's (90 CIN - 90 MON) 0.574
3DAYROTATION 2 13 .92 pirates, jays & padres 0.564
TAXMAN2008 3 22 Youppi in Windy Hogtown 0.527
NOCOMM999 4 24 '91 Red Sox/'90 Pirates/'92 Reds 0.553
.
FOOTBALLMM11 1 7 94 ATL / 93 SFG / 94 CLE 0.605
JOERAT1 2 16 92 Cubs 92 Phillies 92 Pirates 0.502
THEJUICE6 3 18 92TOR 94MON 94NYY 0.620
CALHOOP 4 19 93 ATL - 94 HTN - 94 SD 0.539
.
PEDROCERRANO 1 2 1996 Braves/1996 Rockies/1996 Marlins 0.533
D_ROCK97 2 8 1994 ATL, 1994 MON, 1995 COL 0.593
GLOWGUY 3 9 1994 Yankees/ 1995 Indians/ 1995 Dodgers 0.619
SCHWARZE 4 10 1995 Braves (94 HOU - 96 SEA) 0.576
.
BARRACUDA3 1 3 1997 Braves 1997 Rockies 1998 Padres 0.580
YBJSPORTS 2 5 1998 Atlanta 0.626
RONTHEGENIUS 3 6 96 Braves / 96 Marlins / 98 Blue Jays 0.543
DOUGSDAWGS13 4 17 Indians-Mariners-Yanks 96-98 0.625
.
.
Owner Div# Pick# Team Name - League 9 Win%
--------------------- -------- -------- -------------------------------------------- --------
SCHWARZE 1 4 1998 Braves (99 ARI - 00 LAD) 0.601
BEALLENDALL 2 14 1998 NYY - 1999 ATL - 1999 TEX 0.642
RONTHEGENIUS 3 16 99 Red Sox / 98 Padres / 98 Mariners 0.552
REDCPED 4 18 2000 Red Sox/2000 Braves/1998 Astros 0.580
.
KSTOBER 1 1 02 Red Sox, 02 Diamondbacks, 02 Giants 0.590
PEDROCERRANO 2 7 2001 Mariners/01 D'backs/2000 Braves 0.623
FOOTBALLMM11 3 12 01 OAK / 01 SFG / 01 COL 0.545
BIGSTEVE12 4 13 Bos 00 - Atl 02 - NYY 01 0.583
.
NJBIGWIG 1 2 Bigwig's LG09 - BOS/ATL/LAD 0.574
DARTHDURRON 2 6 2003 OAK/2003 ARIZ/2003 NYY 0.578
D_ROCK97 3 19 2002 ARI, 2003 BOS, 2003 SF 0.604
CHISOCK 4 23 2002 OAK/2004 STL/2002 ATL 0.638
.
CHISOCK 1 3 2005 HOU/2005 NYY/2004 SFG 0.566
SCHWARZE 2 11 2006 Twins (05 NYM - 05 STL) 0.574
GLOWGUY 3 20 2004 Cardinals/2004 Yankees/2005 Marlins 0.595
3DAYROTATION 4 21 .04 twins, 06 mets & yankees 0.588
.
BARRACUDA3 1 5 2006 Twins 2007 Yankees 2008 Dodgers 0.564
RICHIEBROWN6 2 9 07 Red Sox/08 Brewers/07 Phillies 0.566
GWOREAR 3 22 2006 Yankees/2007 Padres/2008 Indians 0.548
STEVEIZZY 4 24 07ATL/07CLE/08NYM 0.553
.
PARKING31 1 8 Red(birds), Wright & Blue M's [08-10] 0.496
TOYSBOYS 2 10 2010 PHI / 2009 NYY / 2010 STL 0.588
THEJUICE6 3 15 08MIL 09BOS 10TEX 0.566
KSTOBER 4 17 09 Dodgers, 08 Indians, 08 Red Sox 0.558
.
.
Owner Div# Pick# Team Name - League 10 Win%
--------------------- -------- -------- -------------------------------------------- --------
TOYSBOYS 1 11 2011 PHI / 2012 DET / 2012 SFG 0.584
NOCOMM999 2 13 '10 Phillies/'11 Dodgers/'12 Braves 0.563
BARRACUDA3 3 15 2011 Tigers 2010 Rangers 2010 Reds 0.568
CHISOCK 4 16 2011 BOS/2011 ANH/2010 STL 0.539
.
DARTHDURRON 1 14 2013 LAD/2012 DET/2014 CUB 0.521
JTPSOPS 2 20 Raising Matt Cain 0.560
GLOWGUY 3 21 2012 Nationals/2013 Mariners/14' Dodgers 0.541
THEJUICE6 4 22 13SLC 13DET 14WAS 0.588
.
REDCPED 1 2 2015 Dodgers/2015 Blue Jays/2014 Angels 0.582
NJBIGWIG 2 10 Bigwig's LG10 - CHC/BOS/WAS 0.575
SCHWARZE 3 17 2015 Cubs (16 CLE - 14 LAD) 0.588
FOOTBALLMM11 4 19 16 WAS / 16 LAD / 16 COL 0.537
.
SCHWARZE 1 3 2016 Cubs (16 LAD - 17 NYY) 0.588
YBJSPORTS 2 6 2018 Boston 0.609
_JJP_ 3 23 Housan Bostocisco Red *** Giants 0.582
BEALLENDALL 4 24 2017 LAD - 2017 CLE - 2017 MIA 0.582
.
BARRACUDA3 1 1 2019 Astros 2020 Indians 2018 Red Sox 0.637
STEVEIZZY 2 8 2020 SD/ATL/CIN 0.572
KSTOBER 3 12 20 Dodgers, 18 Indians, 19 Braves 0.626
MLLAMA54 4 18 19 Dodgers/19 Mets/20 White Sox 0.590
.
RONTHEGENIUS 1 4 2020 Padres / 2020 Dodgers / 2021 Jays 0.632
PEDROCERRANO 2 5 2021 Dodgers/2020 Braves/2020 White Sox 0.607
JE3RD 3 7 Dodgers ‘22/Astros ‘21/Giants ‘21 0.644
HARRELSON 4 9 2022 Mets/Astros/Braves Thick as a Brick 0.634
3/30/2023 3:39 PM (edited)
schwarze
Posts: 44817 (1)
Hall of Famer
1845 74 4 1 1
Hall of Famer
FYI - I simply averaged the three teams' winning%. That was a better method than adding up wins and losses and calculating win% from that. Most of the time, it didn't matter, but for the divisions where there was a different number of games played by year, it did matter (especially for 2020).
3/30/2023 3:33 PM
Round 3 - Winning % by Teams Selected Topic
△Top△Bottom

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2025 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.