It would appear that whatif sports was purchased by people who know nothing about the product or how to fix it. They simply perpetuate a tremendous amount absolute BS to ride this money making wave as far as possible. someone may see this and decide to defend the game and all it's quirks. Most likely they are indeed employed by whatif sports and it is in there best interest to do so.
In my world "Around the Horn" , I signed a pitcher to a max deal in free agency. This pitcher was a, type-A free agent, which would require me to lose my 1st rd.pick below 16. The pitchers former franchise should have been awarded my 1st rd. pick #28 overall. Instead for some strange reason, they were given my 2nd rd. pick #93 overall, along with the typical supplemental pick at the end of rd. 1 that would be given to a type-A free agent. Five days later, which is what ? 15 HBD days. I signed another free agent who was coming down in price. I signed this RP to a 2 year deal worth 2.5 mil. per year. He was also a type-A free agent, and his former club was indeed awarded my 1st rd. pick #28 overall and a higher supplemental pick than the previous for mentioned franchise.