For those of us who hate 1 a day worlds (like me). I joined the mega bowl in Rupp but I just cant get into one a day worlds.

So if you are interested it will be in Phelan.

Signup Date: October 10th

Interested

tmacfan12

We ought to make this one D3!

Quote: Originally posted by aejones on 10/04/2009We ought to make this one D3!

nah D3 is garbage

How full is phelan d2?

The only chance of creating a "super-division" would be at the DIII level. Maintaining a full world is a lot of work and i just dont see the Rupp thing lasting for the long haul. So if you did a 2-a-day world, i would recommend DIII. But you would still need one (probably a few) owners as a driving force, constantly recruiting new coaches for the world.

Its a great idea, and lots of coaches seem to be on board, i just dont see anyone taking the reigns to maintain it. And thats what it will take for anything like this to last.

why is D3 garbage? even more parity and chance for "stars" than d2. seems to me like its pretty much the same as D2 except for the eligibility requirements, which seems like a negligible difference.

If rupp was a div III mega bowl I think I would stay in it. I am going to play in div III one more season there, but I will probabaly drop that world and go to div III wooden.

I wish this happened from the start, I hate 1 a day worlds, and I have an established D2 team already in Phelan.

Quote: Originally posted by aejones on 10/04/2009why is D3 garbage? even more parity and chance for "stars" than d2. seems to me like its pretty much the same as D2 except for the eligibility requirements, which seems like a negligible difference.

how is there more parity in D3? imo there is actually a lot less.

what are you guys talking about? Relative to each division, the level of talent is the same.

The differences between DII and DIII are in the rules. No boosters in DIII. Ineligibles can play in DIII. You get more recruiting money in DII.

Thats it. The main reason why people dont like DIII is because the ratings of players are so low and because there is less margin for error in recruiting.

There are more players in D2 with highs in multiple categories and good cores then there are in D3.

The additional money that you get in D2 makes it better to me. It's nice being able to recruit international players, that really isn't an option at D3.

Quote: Originally posted by tmacfan12 on 10/04/2009There are more players in D2 with highs in multiple categories and good cores then there are in D3.

Maybe, just maybe, that would be why they are in div II rather then div III because they have the extra potential and better cores?

tmac you should join the GNAC in Phelan..

Seaons 2-6 it was by far the best DII conf in Phelan.

Quote: Originally posted by furry_nipps on 10/05/2009

Quote: Originally posted by tmacfan12 on 10/04/2009There are more players in D2 with highs in multiple categories and good cores then there are in D3.

Maybe, just maybe, that would be why they are in div II rather then div III because they have the extra potential and better cores?

and because they have more potential they separate themselves further then the average recruit.