I have to agree ... one game examples just aren't that compelling. Almost anything can happen in one game.
The real question(s) is whether (a) we see a lot more of these games than we should and/or (b) results over a whole season are really skewed.
A is very hard to measure, other than gut feel. Although I wlil say if that if there is an overwhelming majority of similar gut feelings among vets, I would consider that extremely compelling. B is much easier and would present evidence that would be concrete and pretty hard to argue with.