The previous post for drafting players out of position didn't work for me either, so this is how I figured it out. I can't believe Admin doesn't know how to do it. What, is the guy's mom answering sitemails?
First I searched for the ARod I wanted. Then, I rightclicked on his name (Not the green arrow). Then I selected "Properties". Then I copied the unique player number. This is the first number after the parentheses, and was something like 2244050 for the 2009 ARod. Then I went to catcher, or whatever other position I needed to fill, and selected a player - any player, it doesn't matter which one. Now, once selected, on the draft page in the URL box is a bunch of numbers, but the last number is the unique player number for the guy I just drafted. So I went to the URL box, highlighted that number, and pasted ARod's number in its place (2244050, or whatever one I needed). Press Enter and voila.
Still a lot of great pitchers available. After much deliberation, I'll take my chances on ole Pete. Pete Alexander