Here are the 24 nominated players and their two teammate keepers, sorted by total salary.
| Leag |
Owner_______ |
Player |
__Year__ |
Team______________ |
__Pos__ |
_______Salary |
___Total Salary |
| NL |
njbigwig |
Fielder Jones |
1908 |
Chicago White Sox |
OF |
$4,691,184 |
$33,300,461 |
| NL |
njbigwig |
Ed Walsh |
1908 |
Chicago White Sox |
SP |
$18,315,969 |
|
| NL |
njbigwig |
Frank Smith |
1908 |
Chicago White Sox |
SP |
$10,293,308 |
|
| AL |
Oli35 |
Ossee Schreckengost |
1908 |
Chicago White Sox |
C |
$1,637,651 |
$30,246,928 |
| AL |
Oli35 |
Ed Walsh |
1908 |
Chicago White Sox |
SP |
$18,315,969 |
|
| AL |
Oli35 |
Frank Smith |
1908 |
Chicago White Sox |
SP |
$10,293,308 |
|
| AL |
mpitt76 |
Eddie Cicotte |
1912 |
Boston Red Sox |
SP |
$870,137 |
$26,036,748 |
| AL |
mpitt76 |
Joe Wood |
1912 |
Boston Red Sox |
SP |
$14,600,859 |
|
| AL |
mpitt76 |
Tris Speaker |
1912 |
Boston Red Sox |
OF |
$10,565,752 |
|
| AL |
Whiteslave |
Dolph Camilli |
1941 |
Brooklyn Dodgers |
1B |
$6,249,948 |
$25,121,802 |
| AL |
Whiteslave |
Whit Wyatt |
1941 |
Brooklyn Dodgers |
SP |
$10,755,573 |
|
| AL |
Whiteslave |
Pete Reiser |
1941 |
Brooklyn Dodgers |
OF |
$8,116,281 |
|
| AL |
markeking |
Catfish Hunter |
1971 |
Oakland Athletics |
SP |
$8,987,417 |
$24,293,189 |
| AL |
markeking |
Vida Blue |
1971 |
Oakland Athletics |
SP |
$11,545,546 |
|
| AL |
markeking |
Rollie Fingers |
1971 |
Oakland Athletics |
RP |
$3,760,226 |
|
| AL |
shysters3 |
Bobby Doerr |
1949 |
Boston Red Sox |
2B |
$6,696,337 |
$23,841,665 |
| AL |
shysters3 |
Ted Williams |
1949 |
Boston Red Sox |
OF |
$10,425,475 |
|
| AL |
shysters3 |
Johnny Pesky |
1949 |
Boston Red Sox |
3B |
$6,719,853 |
|
| NL |
Whiteslave |
Harvey Haddix |
1953 |
St. Louis Cardinals |
SP |
$8,538,123 |
$23,291,522 |
| NL |
Whiteslave |
Stan Musial |
1953 |
St. Louis Cardinals |
OF |
$7,680,576 |
|
| NL |
Whiteslave |
Red Schoendienst |
1953 |
St. Louis Cardinals |
2B |
$7,072,823 |
|
| AL |
calhoop |
Jim Hearn |
1948 |
St. Louis Cardinals |
RP |
$1,609,101 |
$21,930,818 |
| AL |
calhoop |
Stan Musial |
1948 |
St. Louis Cardinals |
OF |
$11,389,378 |
|
| AL |
calhoop |
Harry Brecheen |
1948 |
St. Louis Cardinals |
SP |
$8,932,339 |
|
| AL |
schwarze |
Nomar Garciaparra |
2002 |
Boston Red Sox |
SS |
$6,063,540 |
$21,628,726 |
| AL |
schwarze |
Pedro Martinez |
2002 |
Boston Red Sox |
SP |
$7,933,813 |
|
| AL |
schwarze |
Derek Lowe |
2002 |
Boston Red Sox |
SP |
$7,631,373 |
|
| NL |
ff09 |
Tony Armas |
1980 |
Oakland Athletics |
OF |
$4,860,018 |
$21,186,629 |
| NL |
ff09 |
Mike Norris |
1980 |
Oakland Athletics |
SP |
$9,259,893 |
|
| NL |
ff09 |
Rickey Henderson |
1980 |
Oakland Athletics |
OF |
$7,066,718 |
|
| AL |
northof49 |
John McGraw |
1898 |
Baltimore Orioles |
3B |
$6,100,389 |
$20,991,689 |
| AL |
northof49 |
Al Maul |
1898 |
Baltimore Orioles |
SP |
$8,121,800 |
|
| AL |
northof49 |
Hughie Jennings |
1898 |
Baltimore Orioles |
SS |
$6,769,500 |
|
| NL |
pmars2001 |
Sandy Koufax |
1965 |
Los Angeles Dodgers |
SP |
$14,039,062 |
$20,882,355 |
| NL |
pmars2001 |
Jim Lefebvre |
1965 |
Los Angeles Dodgers |
2B |
$4,026,299 |
|
| NL |
pmars2001 |
Bob Miller |
1965 |
Los Angeles Dodgers |
RP |
$2,816,994 |
|
| NL |
malinowt |
Tilly Walker |
1912 |
Washington Senators |
OF |
$638,719 |
$20,342,500 |
| NL |
malinowt |
Walter Johnson |
1912 |
Washington Senators |
SP |
$17,525,356 |
|
| NL |
malinowt |
Rip Williams |
1912 |
Washington Senators |
C |
$2,178,425 |
|
| AL |
tracyr |
Ken Williams |
1922 |
St. Louis Browns |
OF |
$8,530,307 |
$20,307,113 |
| AL |
tracyr |
George Sisler |
1922 |
St. Louis Browns |
1B |
$9,705,259 |
|
| AL |
tracyr |
Pat Collins |
1922 |
St. Louis Browns |
C |
$2,071,547 |
|
| AL |
ejstockman |
Norm Charlton |
1995 |
Seattle Mariners |
RP |
$2,858,396 |
$20,188,100 |
| AL |
ejstockman |
Randy Johnson |
1995 |
Seattle Mariners |
SP |
$9,610,808 |
|
| AL |
ejstockman |
Edgar Martinez |
1995 |
Seattle Mariners |
DH |
$7,718,896 |
|
| AL |
malinowt |
Joe Gibbon |
1969 |
San Francisco Giants |
RP |
$1,790,915 |
$19,829,866 |
| AL |
malinowt |
Juan Marichal |
1969 |
San Francisco Giants |
SP |
$9,823,454 |
|
| AL |
malinowt |
Willie McCovey |
1969 |
San Francisco Giants |
1B |
$8,215,497 |
|
| NL |
Donburgh |
Pie Traynor |
1927 |
Pittsburgh Pirates |
3B |
$6,323,826 |
$18,491,960 |
| NL |
Donburgh |
Paul Waner |
1927 |
Pittsburgh Pirates |
OF |
$9,358,523 |
|
| NL |
Donburgh |
Johnny Miljus |
1927 |
Pittsburgh Pirates |
RP |
$2,809,611 |
|
| NL |
calhoop |
Brickyard Kennedy |
1903 |
Pittsburgh Pirates |
SP |
$4,740,679 |
$18,325,953 |
| NL |
calhoop |
Honus Wagner |
1903 |
Pittsburgh Pirates |
SS |
$8,045,406 |
|
| NL |
calhoop |
Fred Clarke |
1903 |
Pittsburgh Pirates |
OF |
$5,539,868 |
|
| NL |
mllama54 |
Lou Boudreau |
1948 |
Cleveland Indians |
SS |
$10,295,613 |
$18,038,339 |
| NL |
mllama54 |
Joe Gordon |
1948 |
Cleveland Indians |
2B |
$5,502,698 |
|
| NL |
mllama54 |
Satchel Paige |
1948 |
Cleveland Indians |
RP |
$2,240,028 |
|
| NL |
marlowe |
Joe Heving |
1938 |
Boston Red Sox |
RP |
$1,822,579 |
$17,653,040 |
| NL |
marlowe |
Jimmie Foxx |
1938 |
Boston Red Sox |
1B |
$9,175,579 |
|
| NL |
marlowe |
Joe Cronin |
1938 |
Boston Red Sox |
SS |
$6,654,882 |
|
| NL |
pedrocerrano |
Jim Brewer |
1972 |
Los Angeles Dodgers |
RP |
$3,471,177 |
$15,805,142 |
| NL |
pedrocerrano |
Don Sutton |
1972 |
Los Angeles Dodgers |
SP |
$10,970,609 |
|
| NL |
pedrocerrano |
Doug Rau |
1972 |
Los Angeles Dodgers |
RP |
$1,363,356 |
|
| AL |
specsman |
Ron Guidry |
1978 |
New York Yankees |
SP |
$10,616,274 |
$15,338,141 |
| AL |
specsman |
Rich Gossage |
1978 |
New York Yankees |
RP |
$4,471,021 |
|
| AL |
specsman |
Jay Johnstone |
1978 |
New York Yankees |
OF |
$250,846 |
|
| NL |
happyhours |
Ramon Martinez |
1990 |
Los Angeles Dodgers |
SP |
$6,644,878 |
$14,435,357 |
| NL |
happyhours |
Eddie Murray |
1990 |
Los Angeles Dodgers |
1B |
$5,541,272 |
|
| NL |
happyhours |
Mike Hartley |
1990 |
Los Angeles Dodgers |
RP |
$2,249,207 |
|
| NL |
shawbigred |
Jorge Posada |
2005 |
New York Yankees |
C |
$3,538,417 |
$7,764,109 |
| NL |
shawbigred |
Mariano Rivera |
2005 |
New York Yankees |
RP |
$3,845,656 |
|
| NL |
shawbigred |
John Flaherty |
2005 |
New York Yankees |
C |
$380,036 |
|