Sorry I've only got one d3 team now so this may be a dumb question:

I've got a guy on my d3 screen, and I'm A+ prestige, but my mail from him says he would never consider my school.
I've never seen this happen in like a zillion seasons.

Is this a bug or does this happen now?

I've never seen it happen either. It'd be worth a ticket to find out.

Is it possible that D2 school is also recruiting him but hasn't done enough to be considered yet?  I don't know if that makes a difference or not

that shouldnt happen.  did he decline effort?

If he isn't recruitable- that's ticket worthy, maybe the overdid the limits for schools

Posted by asher413 on 3/20/2011 9:02:00 PM (view original):
If he isn't recruitable- that's ticket worthy, maybe the overdid the limits for schools

That's what I was thinking ... davey, let us know what they say/resolution.

I turned in a ticket. I didn't think that had changed but I just don't pay as much attention any more and so......

In the end they said "not a bug" but that it was "quirky". Apparently he dropped down and showed on my screen but not down enough to sign d3.
I have to admit I don't really understand that but that's the way it is.

Posted by daveymac on 3/22/2011 4:52:00 PM (view original):
In the end they said "not a bug" but that it was "quirky". Apparently he dropped down and showed on my screen but not down enough to sign d3.
I have to admit I don't really understand that but that's the way it is.

I'm sorry, but I don't find that anwser acceptable.  No one should show up on your division search that you can't sign.  Period.  How is that "not a bug?"

That's just a stupid, stupid response from WIS.  Either he dropped down or he didn't.

I just realized.. i'm in the same leauge as daveymac.

I'm the Coach at Rochester, and seems like your the coach at NY University.

That's clearly a bug, and a potentially enormous one at that. The entire concept of being aggressive in recruiting (pulldowns, battles, etc) is based on having a safety net of D3 recruits that you know for sure you can get considered and signed. Having someone on your division's list who won't consider you is ridiculous.

davey, it's small consolation, but I would at least ask CS to have any recruiting money you spent on that guy refunded.

I would push back and try to get the ticket escalated.

"quirky" but not a "bug"????  That's like Jim Calhoun "We may have broken the  rules, but we didn't cheat."

I assume WIS actually checked for a bug??? Or did they just run the Quirky app?

id be ******

lol,. well who knows. Yes Frank we're in the same league good luck this year. Oh and they did refund my money on the guy, $290.