Way back in DIII in Knight I had a game that went into triple over time, but if you combined my and my opponent's scores it would still have been less points than how many your team scored alone.
Some clutch shots by Holt in there, and just an insane game overall. Most ridiculous thing I remember is quite awhile back when someone posted something on the forum about a team winning the national championship on a half-court shot at the buzzer.