I would say it depends primarily on how many guys you want to recruit with the money your open scholarships give you. I can't think of any case in which I would cut more than 2. If I had less than 4 scholarships open, I wouldn't want to have to recruit any more than 2 extra guys with my money or I'd get spread too thin. If I had 4 or more I wouldn't want to add more guys into the same recruiting class.