Name	Yr.	Pos.	A	SPD	REB	DE	BLK	LP	PE	BH	P	WE	ST	DU	FT	TOT
Lawrence Hall	So.	PG	42	71	1	50	1	10	15	58	28	47	79	53	C-	455
James Camargo	So.	SG	30	68	12	36	13	23	28	41	39	51	72	69	C-	482

Presuming similar potentials for the future, which one of these two would you try to redshirt, given the current team?

It's tough guessing on potential...

If the pg doesn't have high in passing then I would likely not want him to be playing an extra 5th year as his passing would cap below 48.

Hall has high potential in passing, I just concentrated on speed, ATH and defense from him in the first year.   Still should have allot of ATH(Was high-high there), and defense(Was high-high there), also at least high in BH, Passing, Stamina, FT shooting, limited in LP and PER, avg in everything else.

Camargo at high-high in stamina and defense, at least high  in Low Post, Perimeter, FT shooting - only limited in shot blocking. (Was almost thinking of him in more of a small forward/backup guard role.)

On all of the highs that aren't listed at high-high, they COULD be, I just only got scouting reports for the ones listed as high-high.