I'm struggling between two PG recruits who are very similar. Either one would redshirt this season and play very limited minutes next season, and WE is almost identical between the two. So lots of time to develop for either.

The first guy will likely end up somewhere in this neighborhood:

Ath 65-70
Spd 85
Def 75-80
Per 60
BH 80
Pass 85
Stamina 70

Guy number two:

Ath 55
Spd 90+
Def 55-60
Per 50
BH 70
Pass 85-90
Stamina 90+


I'm leaning towards guy number one, but the second guy's slightly higher speed and pass and much higher stamina is appealing. Is a 70 stamina too low for a DI PG?

oh sorry, should have mentioned I run motion/man

I wouldn't even consider this a contest in any system.

ha alright then

i take #1 100 times out of 100

fair enough.

#2 also has a LP cap of about 40, whereas #1 starts with 1 and low potential. I don't suppose that makes a difference?

I'd say it makes a difference, but #1 still wins.

ended up signing the first guy. not sure what I was thinking yesterday. I tend to get too enamored with a few extra points in speed and passing at times