Durability and Stamina Topic

Please help me understand these ratings?

Is stamina the suggested maximum # of pitches per game?

Wha is durability (can you provide an example)?

In general is a rating of 100 the best rating and 0 the worst in all categories?

Thank you
1/22/2012 8:48 AM
1. Stamina refers to how much a pitcher can pitch. A pitcher with 70 stamina might be able to go 6+ innings every outing, but another pitcher who only has 20 stamina might only go one inning. Therefore, when choosing who to start and who to use in the bullpen, stamina should be an important factor, but not necessarily the deciding one. Usually I try to make sure my starters have stamina of 60+, but if they have dynamite stuff and only 50 stamina (see  Al Serra) then they could conceivably still be starters. Long Relief guys usually need to have 45+, but they are weaker than your starters. Everyone else I use as Setup A or B, since I don't use a closer.

2. Durability refers to how soon a pitcher can pitch again after an outing. In real life, some pitchers (relievers mostly) can pitch every other day, like RL closers. Well, in here, some pitchers can do this too. Starters usually have anywhere from 15-40 durability, meaning they can pitch every 3rd-6th day or so. IF you can find a good starter with 30+ durability, you are in business. Relievers can have anywhere from starter durability to 80 or even 90 durability (these guys usually have low stamina, so they pitch about an inning an outing, but they might can do that for 3 days straight, have one off day, then do it again.) So durability is important in pitchers.

Durability also refers to how soon a position player needs a rest. If they have 70 durability, they might only can play 120 games, but a guy with 95 durability can play 150 or 155.

3. This is generally correct, except for a few categories. For batters, this means the push/pull rating. A low rating means an extreme pull hitter, but a higher rating means extreme push hitter. Someone with a 50 rating will hit it both ways about the same, but someone with a 100 will hit it almost exclusively to the opposite field.

For pitchers, there is the FB/GB tendency. This is tricky, because a higher rating is viewed as better, but it doesn't have to be. If a pitcher has a low GB/FB rate, he will pitch more flyballs, and a high rating means more ground balls. If he has a higher rating, in theory, this will lead to a higher rate of double plays and the like, with less sacrifice flies. But you can find a pitcher who can do it well with low GB/FBs. While  Gorkys Romero  uses his high rating to his advantage, you can find dynamite pitchers like Wilfredo Garrido, who can still be electric with a low rating.                                                                                              Hope this helped.




1/22/2012 9:37 AM
Only thing I might add is that if you are trying to estimate how many innings you might get out of a pitcher based on STA/DUR, don't forget to factor in the quality of the pitcher, defense and park. It may sound obvious, but it matters when constructing your pitching staff at the beginning of a season. If you don't plan for it properly, fatigue issues can really be painful later in the season.
1/22/2012 10:01 AM
For starting pitchers, I usually add about 20 to the Stamina # to get TPC and then another 15 to that to get MPC.  For my bullpen guys it really depends on their Durability what their pitch count looks like.  I want those guys available as often as possible. Durability is basically how fast a guy recovers to pitch again.

A starter with a Durability of 30 is pretty durable. My 5 starters this year had scores of 24, 24, 27, 30 and 32.

My best bullpen guy, OrlandoBonilla has a Durability of 19 and a Stamina of 62.  He's relly a starter type guy who needs rest if his pitch count gets up, so I set his TPC at 30 and his MPC at 40.  Got 118 innings out of him with a 2.74 ERA.  If I started him I could proably get about 175 innings out of him.  He may start next year.

CyMcDowell has a Durability of 86, but only throws about 15 pitches.  I keep his pitch count low so I can use him when needed.
1/22/2012 10:32 AM
Durability and Stamina Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2026 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.