So i've been busy and kind of left this for a month.  There were 40-45 responses.  Here are the results. Some of these issues have been cleared up but here's a list of what issues people found most important (1 being the lowest possible score and 5 being the highest possible score):

Scouting Trips	4.17
FAQ Update	4.05
Team Prestige/Baseline Prestige Correlation	3.88
D1 Promotion Logic	3.85
D1 Recruit Generation	3.82
Potential	3.66
Info Boxes For New Users	3.61
Engine Randomness	3.55
Non-BCS Schools and EE's	3.55
Early Recruiting Actions for Initial Cycle	3.51
Baseline Prestige Adjustment to Level Playing Field	3.46
5 Player Rule	3.46
Players Career Info Kept After They Leave	3.44
Difficulty for Job Jumpers to take High Prestige Programs	3.38
D2/3 Prestige and Impact of Most Reason Season	3.34
Pre-Season Tournaments	3.30
Postseason Seeding	3.29
Postseason Recruiting Funds	3.28
Mass Recruiting Options	3.24
Off Days Limited	3.24
Increased Info on Resume Page	3.24
Promise Starts as Sophomores	3.22
Prestige Affected By Not Playing Senior Transfers	3.22
Pipeline States	3.20
Potential on Ratings Page	3.20
Generating Recruits Based on Where Progams Are	3.14
New Offensive and Defensive Systems	3.13
Be Able To See HS Junior Recruits	3.07
Advanced Statistics	3.05
Player Roles	2.93
FSS for International Prospects	2.91
Injuries	2.90
Amount of Half/Full Court Shots	2.88
First Recruiting Cycle Length	2.87
More Time Between Getting Recruiting Funds and Recruiting	2.87
Quick Shot Offense	2.78
Sorting Players By Intended Position	2.76
Ability for Coaches to View Other Worlds	2.59

Probably too small of a sample size to show anything, but gives a general idea of what the HD community thinks.