what defense do you play?

Currently running a zone/press.

Ok fixed. Assuming enough people haven't seen it yet :)

Posted with potential ending ratings.
Plus ratings indicate tremendous growth from beginning. non plus indicate either low potential or unkown level of growth.

 

Name	Pos.				A	SPD		DE			PE	BH	P
player a	PG				35	90 +		15			80+	80+	70+
player b	PG				50	80 +		70			35	60+	50

Not a good idea to post exact ratings with potentials.  You're giving all those potentials to everybody whether they've scouted the states these guys are in or not.

to me id go with number one because hes got perimeter passing and good ball handling but his only problem is his defense. oh wait theres one more problem... HES OUT FOR EVERYONE TO SEE

Fair enough. mistake on my part, also did not realize I had the name linked. Ok I've fixed the post. Luckily I set it out late last night, so maybe not too many have seen it lol.

Now with that said. Is player 1's defense a big enough issue to take player 2 over him?

Player 1 wouldn't even make my search with that defense.  Even in the zone he is a liability. I'll take the +15 ath and +55(!) def guy without thinking twice. 

I know it is difficult to find very good ball handlers and passers at DIII, but I would keep looking.  Maybe you could find a perimeter guy to play the other guard position or the 3.