Talkin Baseball Reboot - FULL Topic

The original Talkin' Baseball progressive league completed 75 seasons (1951 through 2024). We had so much fun that we decided to do it all over again! The Talkin' Baseball Reboot League started with the 1961 season. One of the owners went MIA near the end of the 1966 draft. We are looking to add one owner to join us in the 1966 season and beyond. We ask that you give us at least a six season commitment (gentleman's agreement), as we are really interested in attracting a long term owner. 3/4 of the current owners have been in this league for 50+ seasons! As you may be able to tell, we are a long running, stable league. If you aren't able or willing to commit to at least 6 seasons with us, we do appreciate you looking at this but this league would not be a good fit for either you or us.

This is a plug and play scenario. Commit to taking over the team, make your last 2 draft picks from the remaining list of available players, enter your team and then the season will begin (all other owners are entered and ready). The available roster is posted in the last post of this thread. Home park is Yankee Stadium (I) (HR LF/RF:-1/-1 1B:-2 2B:0 3B:1) and you'll reside in the AL East.

I can certainly provide access to our private forum to anyone who is interested in joining us. Below is a quick overview:
  • 16 team single season progressive which began with the 1961 season. IMPORTANT: We will be expanding to 20 teams starting with the 1969 season. In order to do this, the existing 16 teams will likely not have the 1969 first year players available to them as they will all go to the expansion teams. We will be discussing expansion details as a league during the 1966 season and get those details finalized, but again please know going in that you likely won't have a chance at any of the 1969 first year players.
  • No DH to start with. We will take a league vote soon to determine if we will add the DH starting with 1973 season, and if so, if we will do AL only or both leagues.
  • Injuries on
  • No live play
  • Unlimited IR
  • No salary cap
  • For seasons 1961 through 1981 or so we will use WIS auto-generated players. AAA player quality below average. Real names (you will just need to figure out the year of that player if you are so inclined). 6 bats (C,1B,2B,SS,3B,OF) and 2 arms (starter and reliever) will be automatically assigned to each team each season. We will draft our own AAA players beginning sometime between 1982 and 1987 (subject to league vote) from the leftover players who aren't drafted in the regular draft
  • Full/combined/partial seasons of players are all eligible to be used.
  • Trading of draft picks allowed up to one season in advance (we will likely discuss and vote to possibly allow up to two seasons in advance as the suggestion has been made). I have no idea if the majority will want this or not, but please be aware that we will have a vote on this soon.
  • We have a 48 hour add/drop period after each draft.
  • We absolutely do not condone tanking games in this league. This has never been much of an issue here and the league takes great pride in that. Eyes are always watching, and even the appearance of tanking games can lead to dismissal from the league, period. If you play progressive leagues using this strategy, then you aren't welcome here. If you want to play in a league where everyone is trying to do their best regardless of what their roster looks like in any given season, then please choose us!
  • You have the ability to shuffle players up and down from AAA virtually all season (deadline is before game 160 of the season).
4/12/2026 12:20 AM (edited)
There are a LOT of details that go into most any progressive league, so please feel free to ask any questions!

A four-tier lotto system (4/4/4/4) is used to determine next season's first round draft order after 120 games. 4 worst teams get put in lotto for picks 1 through 4 in next season's draft. Next 4 worst teams get put in a lotto for picks 5 through 8, and so on. Lotto is for the first round of the draft only. Subsequent rounds are worst team to best team, based on record at 120 games into the current season. There is a 30 win minimum requirement by the 120th game into the season to qualify for a top 4 pick. Teams that do not have 30 wins by the 120th game into the season get dropped down to the second lotto tier (for a pick between #5 and #8 in round one).

There is typically not a lot of down time between seasons. On average, we are starting the next season about one week after the World Series concludes.
Important: We attempt to keep things moving at a semi-brisk pace. We start drafting off the clock not too long after the 120 game mark at a leisurely pace. Once the playoffs start, we draft on the clock and pick up wherever we are in the draft at that point. We attempt to keep down time to a minimum between seasons, as we usually finish the draft around the same time that the World Series is finishing up. So keep in mind when considering our league that we move faster than the typical progressive, which may suit you very well or not so well. Missing deadlines to post keeper lists, making draft picks off the clock within 48 hours of the prior pick posted, and entering teams for the new season on time have not often been an issue in this league. We have certainly been fortunate to have such a terrific group of owners, and we do expect new owners to also be able to consistently meet the above noted deadlines.

We will expand to 20 teams starting with the 1969 season and to 24 teams starting with the 1977 season.

Currently 4 teams in each division and 4 divisions. Division winners play in the post-season. Divisions will be aligned considering MLB history and geography.
4/12/2026 12:23 AM (edited)
great league
5/29/2013 8:25 PM (edited)
Posted by houseofbayne on 4/21/2013 10:26:00 PM (view original):
The Talkin' Baseball league is a fairly standard, single season progressive: Alternate WIS Format E (4 divisions, 4 teams in each. Division winners make playoffs. Each series best of seven). No DH. No live play. Unlimited IR. No salary cap. 6/2 below average AAA players, randomly generated (6 bats, 2 arms).

A two-tier lotto system to determine next season's first round draft order after 120 games. 8 worst teams get put in lotto for picks 1 through 8 in next season's draft, 8 best teams get put in lotto for picks 9 through 16. Lotto is for first round of draft only. Subsequent rounds are worst team to best team.
 
As you read this, we are talking about expanding from 16 to 20 teams in the future. This won't happen before 1969. The goal is to have an expansion plan in place within a week or three.
 
We attempt to keep things moving at a semi-brisk pace. We start drafting off the clock not too long after the 120 game mark at a leisurely pace. Once the playoffs start, we draft on the clock and pick up wherever we are in the draft at that point. We attempt to keep down time to a minimum between seasons, as we usually finish the draft around the same time that the World Series is finishing up.
 
 
Feel free to sitemail or post any questions, and looking forward to hearing from you! Team available is below.






                 Curious on how you decide to handle Expansion. Posting to more easily follow your League's process.



 
4/24/2013 3:38 AM
great league guys....expansion challenges all...we even have a HOF.
8/25/2013 12:10 AM
I'd like this team if it's still available
8/24/2014 3:26 PM
I'll take the Trucks.
11/1/2014 10:04 PM
I'll take the Reds and make the commitment if you'll have me.
11/15/2014 2:06 AM
Did you get your 4 owners?
11/29/2014 4:34 PM
Posted by ff09 on 11/29/2014 4:34:00 PM (view original):
Did you get your 4 owners?
We tentatively have four, but would like to start a short waitlist in the event that one or more back out when it comes time to start the expansion draft (estimated to start around mid-February 2015).
11/29/2014 5:02 PM
sign me up on waitlist
11/29/2014 7:29 PM
id be interested in an expansion team
12/2/2014 6:30 PM
Please give me the Houston team. I see that there are 23 active and 2 players are on injured reserve. So, I can keep however many players that I want. If I cut players then I must fill their spots via draft (or free agency or trade). I'm ready. Let me know if i'm in, so I can hire my fron office,lol. I'm ready!
2/21/2016 7:13 PM
i would like to try a progressive....this sounds like a good one
2/10/2017 4:40 PM
I'll take Chicago but the ringworms not so much
4/15/2018 10:34 AM
123 Next ▸
Talkin Baseball Reboot - FULL Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2026 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.