Draft coming up and these guys will be gone before I can pick at #23, but ranking them was interesting for me.  Thought I would see how you guys would rank these three players, in no particular order.  All HS guys. All 18.  I have $17M in HS Scouting.  Projections as as follows...

#1:  Bats R     Glove 58-59-59-60    Bat  66-62-70-99-87    Durability-Health-Makeup  87-97-69           Speed-Baserunning  51-83  
#2   Bats R     Glove 66-58-71-66    Bat  53-73-66-100-61  Durability-Health-Makeup  82-100-100      Speed-Baserunning  74-52
#3   Bats S      Glove 71-75-51-66   Bat 75-81-66-69-67      Durability-Health-Makeup  95-100-88        Speed-Baserunning  74-57 

#1 has the Eye and Baserunning advantage, but the Makeup is lower and he has the defensive disadvantage, too..Fits best at 1B.
#2 has three 100's!  Love the 100 Makeup, could play in RF, but doesn't have th Eye of #1.
#3 plays everyday.  Would be an excellent LF, has the Contact and Power advantage and is a switchhitter

Are you sure they'll be gone by 23? I think that's exactly the spot where corner players like these tend to be taken.

I would rank 1 the highest, though 2 is close. 1 will be a pretty good on base guy, and he could hit 20 homers in the right park. None of these guys are real base stealing threats, and none play a premium position, so I don't put much stock in the speed and defense ratings. I'd rank them in order, 1,2,3. But it's fairly close.

#3 COULD play 2B if he's right-handed.  He'd be a below-average defender, but his bat would make up for it, making him more valuable than 1 or 2, IMO.  If he's left-handed, nevermind.

If he's left-handed, I'd rank them 1-2-3.

And my HS scouting is 0, moe, so don't worry. :)

I'm backwards. I would go #3 as highest. I really like switch hitters, and power guys. Not to mention he has the best defense