When I was at a mid major I made the same mistake that I think you are making. When recruiting I wanted the best talent possible to try to compete with the big boys. What I learned is it is better to build a cohesive team than just a collection of talent, that may not fit together. You seem to focus too much on PER. I love PER, PER is great, but you have so many shooters that you are experiencing diminishing returns on their talent. I try to set up my teams to have a good distributor, 2 scorers (1 outside and 1 inside ideally), 2 rebounders and hopefully everyone plays decent D. Don't be afraid to use a defensive stopper(Bandy) that is not going to score if you already have plenty of offense. You have an impressive group of players for a mid major, but they are all too similar. You could use a couple of specialists (especially a PG who can pass and dribble), who are usually easier to recruit anyway.