Hard to say the guy is a star when he's only putting up 5.6 ppg. Feed him the ball some more. 

you don't have to have a stud or a star to have a great team, you can just have a bunch of great players.

You need stars to win the whole things.

I didnt vote because I dont see where this guy fits into those categories..  He is a superstar defender.  You can find a lot of these guys during recruiting.  They look great but dont really have a position.  I guess his best fit is at SF, but that 19 passing is well below what I would consider acceptable even at DIII.  He is averaging 2.1 turnovers in very limited touches.  If he were the focus of your offense that would likely double.  His 24 rebounding keeps him from being able to play PF.  

So, superstar defender and below average offensive player? 

He is a good piece if used correctly, which it looks like you are doing.

I don't think 19 is terribly low for a D3 SF, especially if you have good passing at the 1 and 2. Heck, I really only shoot for 30 PAS at the 3 normally. And he has decent enough BH where he could probably double his scoring average without going much over 3 TO per game