2 Gabby Hartnett
4 Hack Wilson
7 Barry Bonds
11 Jeff Kent
13 Edgardo Alfonzo
18 Randy Velarde
20 Joe Horlen
21 Jim Brewer
23 Rick Auerbach
25 Rickey Henderson
27 Don Sutton
28 Al Simmons
33 Eddie Murray
34 Dave Giusti
35 Tiny Bonham
39 Roy Smalley
45 Pedro Martinez
47 Hoyt Wilhelm
50 Paul Assenmacher
53 Darren O'day
56 Pedro Astacio
61 Robinson Chirinos
63 Jesus Montero
70 Jeff Fiorentino
99 Manny Ramirez

49- Jake Arrieta
71- Johnny Hodapp
68- Dellin Betances
4- Ralph Kiner
14- Vida Blue
11- Mark Grudzielanek
44- Paul Goldschmidt
20- Kevin Seitzer
16- Del Kendall
57- Eric Valent
36- Derick Norris
30- Michael Conforto
19- Billy Pierce
12- Shawn Dunston
73- Ricardo Rincon
72- Pat Neshek
64- A.J. Griffin
37- Rudy Seanez
2- Paul Revere
10- Edwin Encarnacion
99- Hyun Jin Ryu
33- Matt Harvey
88- Albert Belle
52- Yoenis Cespedes
58- Antonio Bastardo

Here we are:

1-LUIS CASTILLO
7-BOBBY WINE
9-TED WILLIAMS
13-OMAR VIZQUEL
14-MARTIN PRADO
16-HAL NEWHOUSER
21-DAVID SEGUI
22-CLAYTON KERSHAW
25-JIM THOME
29-VINCE COLEMAN
35-MANNY SANGUILLEN
41-JEFF REARDON
49-BILL HANDS
50-J.R. RICHARD
55-MATT CAPPS
56-GREG HOLLAND
58-DOUG FISTER
59-ERIC O'FLAHERTY
64-EMILIO BONIFACIO
66-JOHN RYAN MURPHY
68-TURNER WARD
71-SCOTT LINEBRINK
73-ANDREW ROMINE
77-REGGIE WILLITS
99-MANNY RAMIREZ

2- Granny Hamner
4- Dolph Camilli
6 - Melvin Mora
7 - Mickey Mantle
9 - Cal Ripken
9 - Joe Astroth
14 - Ed Ott
18 - Jeff Conine
23 - Tippy Martinez
25 - Monty Stratton
29 - Doug Bird
33 - Matt Harvey
34 - Bryce Harper
40 - John Denny
41 - Tom Seaver
42 - Jackie Robinson
44 - Jeff Reardon
45 - Bob Gibson
62 - Joba Chamberlin
66- Gerry Staley
65 - Phil Hughes
68 - Yan Gomes
71 - Johnny Hodapp
75 - Barry Zito
88 - Rene Gonzales

17 Omar Vizquel
31 Dave Winfield
44 Paul Goldschmidt
34 Brooks Robinson
26 Steve Farr
29 Catfish Hunter
54 Jayson Werth
50 Chris Carpenter
53 Don Drysdale
61 Jesse Orosco
21 Sammy Sosa
77 Ivan Rodriguez
8 Yogi Berra
71 Scott Linebrink
43 Trever Miller
14 Pete Rose
46 Juan Marichal
9 Chone Figgins
68 Didi Gregorius
1 Richie Ashburn
70 Matt Belisle
57 Randy Johnson
24 Willie Mays
42 Mariano Rivera
2 Roberto Alomar

For Random #s, Consistent Budweisers
42 Mariano Rivera - one note - there are a ton of stars who wore 42 as a tribute to Jackie Robinson and are listed at that number, e.g. Pujols and Bonds. You might limit 42 to players, such as Rivera, who wore the uniform # other than on Jackie Robinson Day.
24 Ricky Henderson
99 Alfredo Amezaga
45 Dennis Rasmussen
59 Dennys Reyes
55 Ron Fairly
46 Miguel Dilone
22 Dizzy Dean
72 Carlton Fisk
7 Joe Mauer
64 Jaime Garcia
51 Willie McGee
54 Jose Valentin
17 Dazzy Vance
5 Jeff Burroughs
48 Kyle Farnsworth
44 Blo Jo a/k/a HoJo a/k/a Howard Johnson
28 Bob Wickman
10 Bip Roberts
88 Mike Ramsey
18 Ben Zobrist
31 Some P named Maddux
33 Pat Jarvis
32 Sandy Koufax
9 Gregg Jeffries

From Fatboydad
55 Tim Lincecum 
17 Bret Saberhagen
9 Reggie Jackson 
77 Tony Batista
56 Hong-Chih Kuo
19 Koji Uehara 
43 Dennis Eckersley
53 Arthur Rhodes 
33 Bobby Abreu 
2 Mickey Cochrane
11 Carl Hubbell 
5 Mel Ott 
67 Sean Doolittle 
4 Luke Appling 
58 Jonathan Papelbon 
52 Boof Bonser
13 Mort Cooper 
34 David Ortiz
25 Willie Randolph 
32 Tim Raines 
68 Jose Iglesias
18 Geovany Soto 
30 Rocky Bridges 
12 Dusty Baker 
36 Dwayne Murphy

5- OF Babe Herman
7- SS Jose Reyes
9- 2B Rogers Hornsby
22- P Dizzy Dean
24- 3B Bob Elliott
26- P Dave McNally
27- OF Lance Berkman
29 P Grant Jackson
30- OF Ken Griffey,Jr
33- P Luis Tiant
34- P Bill Hands
37- P Dennis Eckersley
39- OF Rickey Henderson
42- SS Jimmy Rollins
45- P Pedro Martinez
54- C Kelly Stinnett
58- OF Brian Giles
62-P Jim Poole
63- C JEsus Montero
65- P Tony Watson
68- INF Jose Iglesias
70 P George Kontos
72- P Jack McDowell
73- INF- Andrew Romine
77- C Ivan Rodriguez

0- Omar Quintanilla
4- Bill North
5- Ian Kinsler
7- Eddie Lake
8- Andre Dawson
16- Roger Wolff
17- Dizzy Dean
25- Rickey Henderson
27- Kevin Brown
28- Dolph Camilli
33 - Buddy Lewis
38- Gene Tenace
43- Dutch Meyer
49- Jerry Reuss
50- Steve Ontiveros
53- Bob Milacki
55- Orel Hershiser
61- Red Barrett
62- Wilson Delgado
63- Mike MacDougal
67- Chien-Ming Wang
71- JC Gutierrez (Juan)
75- Mike Walker
88- David Wainhouse
99- Charlie Keller

 

INGLORIOUS  Numbers

75           Paco Rodriguez/P 
60           Wil Nieves/C
36           Stu Miller/P
7             Leon Roberts/OF
31           Pete Harnish/P
20           Mike Olt/3B
6             Bill Almon/SS
28           Harry Danning/C
00           Curtis Goodwin/OF
70           George Kontos/P
30           Tim Raines/OF
43           Charlie Neal/3B
47           Don McMahon/P
19           Vic Raschi/P
56           Pablo Sandoval/3B
41           Jose DeLeon/P
4             Marty Marion/SS
38           Billy O’Dell/P
65           Tony Watson/P
29           Dave Collins/OF
57           Juan Guzman/P
3             Ian Kinsler/2B
61           Ed Morgan/1B
49           Doug Brocail/P
99           Manny Ramirez/OF

Inconceivable

0 - Omar Quintanilla
4  -  Eddie Lake
10 - Andre Dawson
11 - Boom-Boom Beck
17 - Roger Wolff
18 - Joe Morgan
20 - Wally Moon
24 - Bobby Bonilla
25 - Rickey Henderson
29 - Jack Quinn
30 - Greg Maddux
36 - Bill North
38 - Ray Starr
44 - Mike Caldwell
54 - Mike MacDougal
57 - Gary Carter
58 - Jose Morales
61 - Red Barrett
62 - Wilson Delgado
67 - Chien-Ming Wang
68 - Dioner Navarro
70 - Matt Belisle
72 - Jack McDowell
77 - Matt Herges
88 - Rick White

2nd team

00	bobby bonds
0	ortiz
5	dimaggio
14	banks
19	almon
20	sutton
26	boggs
28	herr
31	waner
32	koufax
38	saberhagen
43	eckersley
44	aaron
52	halladay
53	rhodes
55	lowe
56	astacio
58	liriano
66	konerko
67	polanco
68	nady
70	hughes
71	dessens
72	fisk
75	rodriguez