Just getting back into HBD after some years away. And I takeover a bad team and have the #1 pick.

It seems everyone has their flaws and I don't know which direction to go with this pick. I spent 20 in Coll and 16 in HS I think I know the answer but need confirmation. Thanks for the help.


DUR/ST CON L R VEL GB 1 2 3 4 5 MAKEUP HEALTH
P1 22YO 40/73 88 79 89 37 44 76 54 40 41 35 73 84
P2 18YO 15/84 85 82 87 100 87 82 78 65 54 37 52 88
P3 19YO 19/78 100 76 51 40 86 69 90 95 81 57 73 72
P4 18YO 23/89 79 86 83 24 43 89 92 47 47 79 100

RA GL ARM ACC CON PWR L R EYE SPD MAKE HEALTH
2B1 18YO 70 95 49 79 75 93 78 59 82 95 90 76 (Listed as prob. won't sign)
2B2 20YO 84 100 57 65 70 87 82 47 59 89 81 77
2B3 18YO 76 100 53 52 73 50 80 85 69 84 67 96 (58 DUR)


ugh, this lined up better in my post... let me know if I need to make this easier to read.

I think I would either take P2 and hope his Dur is higher than 15, or take P4.

EDIT: actually, I think I'd take P4. Just saw P2's makeup. Wouldn't want to go into the #1 pick hoping my scouts are wrong about his durability AND makeup, and wrong in a good way.

IMO, P1's 2nd pitch is a fatal flaw.
P2's durability & makeup are fatal flaws.
P3's vR is a fatal flaw.

2B1's vR isn't horrible, but I'd want better in such a key rating at 1st round, 1st pick.
2B2's vR is a fatal flaw.
2B3's durability is a killer (~400 AB's a year?), and won't hit for much power.

P4 is the "last man standing," in my opinion - and looks like he'd be a stud SP.