JUCO vs freshman recruiting Topic

3rd season.

I'm getting blasted pretty good by teams that recruited JUCO(3rd season for all of us). I keep telling myself, in the long game, I'll come out in better shape. I'm thinking my players have a higher ceiling(in general) and their IQ will be far superior by their JR/SR seasons.

Am I on the right track? I see JUCO as a stopgap when you just didn't develop anyone at that position and not a viable option to compete year in, year out.
2/28/2017 9:06 AM
jucos can be quite advantageous, especially if you redshirt them. that's the main way I use them, although this season I did actually grab a shooter that I'll only keep for 2 seasons.

I've never really thought it was more advantageous or less, but rather all about the overall team dynamic. It's all about deciding when you want your team to peak and building the roster accordingly. It's hard to with national title without having a lot of juniors and seniors - and I think how many of them were jucos doesn't really matter. also, sometimes a juco will play your offense/defense and then there is not the IQ deficit.
2/28/2017 9:27 AM
I think this is a supply and demand thing - if others in your area, in your world are ignoring jucos then grab the good ones - esp if they know your system

aside from that, jucos can be very helpful when recruiting goes badly or EEs hit you hard and you want to patch gaps

Seems to me that 3.0 has made it less easy to focus/target in search on jucos - and so the supply demand balance may have changed from 2.0
2/28/2017 9:55 AM


ATHLETICISM 60 Blue
SPEED 38 Black
REBOUNDING 45 Green
DEFENSE 62 Black
SHOT BLOCKING 34 Black
LOW-POST 43 Green
PERIMETER 15 Green
BALL HANDLING 14 Green
PASSING 27 Green
WORK ETHIC 62
STAMINA 60 Black
DURABILITY 72
FT SHOOTING B- Yellow

I just signed (and will RS) this JUCO big. I think for JUCO's it's more important that they:

1. Know your O and/or D
2. Have a high (60+) WE

I thinkI'll get 60ish points of growth out out of him his RS year and then 100 his JR. year and maybe 60-80 his senior.


I am fully expecting him to look like this at the end of his SR. year.
ATHLETICISM 80
SPEED 50
REBOUNDING 75
DEFENSE 75
SHOT BLOCKING 45
LOW-POST 75+
PERIMETER 35+
BALL HANDLING 35
PASSING 50
WORK ETHIC 62
STAMINA 70
DURABILITY 72
FT SHOOTING B-


If everything goes right, he'll be my scorer of the bench at 3/4 and play maybe 15 minutes a game.
2/28/2017 10:22 AM
Type A SPD REB DE BLK LP PE BH P WE ST DU FT OVR
Current 43 41 52 40 45 76 53 48 42 62 71 56 C 629
Season Start 43 40 50 36 42 76 47 43 37 56 70 53 C- 593
Season End 42 39 49 35 41 76 45 43 37 56 72 53 C- 588
Season Start 42 38 48 28 36 76 30 30 29 47 72 51 C- 527


I signed this guy in my 1st recruiting season. He knew my O/D and is A in both as a SR. He's been a solid contributor, 9.4 pts/5.2 reb in 25 mpg over 48 games. But he's not leading me to a tourney in D3. And I signed another with 90+ REB/BLK to play back-up C for two seasons in my 2nd season. I just couldn't see signing 2-3 a season to be major contributors. But maybe I'm missing something.
2/28/2017 10:35 AM
That guy just isn't very good. It's not that JUCO's can't be good, it's that guys like that aren't good.

Every know and then a JUCO can be dominant but mostly these are sold role players.
2/28/2017 10:48 AM
https://www.whatifsports.com/hd/PlayerHistory/Ratings.aspx?pid=3261000

This guy was a JUCO though....F'ing stud.
2/28/2017 10:51 AM
Wow that guy is nuts TJ.

Here is my best Juco.

http://imgur.com/bNgW9pu
2/28/2017 11:07 AM
I would agree with fd, it's harder to find and recruit jucos in 3.0. Previously, it wasn't uncommon to see guys using the "superclass" method to replace 6 outgoing seniors with 6 pretty solid juco juniors, and make another run. It would be harder to pull off now, I would think, unless you are in a advantageous geographical spot, and can easily draw from a big local pool. Cal, Tex, NY, FL are the big juco producers that I know of. It's very hard to fully scout, and then effectively recruit in all of them now.

In 3.0, I see the big value of juco players for rebuilding programs, especially in helping you get your class structure set the way you want it. They can fill in gaps, they turn around fast. So even if they don't fill potential, or fully learn your O/D, they can be assets off the bench, and they don't take up a roster spot for 2 extra years to get useful while you try to hide them. With CSUN, I was looking at 10 openings last season, and of course you only get resources adjusted to 6, and can only sign 6 players in a class. So I focused on jucos. I could do that, being in a juco-rich area. They can be good placeholders.
2/28/2017 11:14 AM
When I signed on, I inherited a senior dominated team that won the conference and a NT game. Downside was I had a ton to replace (after a couple of cuts, I signed 8 or 9). I'm with Mike in a full Little East that talks a little trash on the conference chat, so I absolutely did not want to go from first to worst. I filled 5 of my spots with JUCOs hoping to stay competitive. It has worked out, but the downside is that after this season (their 2nd year) I have to replace my 5 best players already. I already have one JUCO picked out that I'm going all out for, but pretty sure I won't be signing that many to one class again.
2/28/2017 11:53 AM
JUCO vs freshman recruiting Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2026 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.