#1

SP 22yrs R/R
General & Fielding Ratings

Event	Season	HT	WT							Dur	Hlt
Projected	-	5-11	190	87	23	18	53	100	10	29	91	4	60	3	81

Batting & Pitching Ratings

Event	Season									Sta	Con	vsL	vsR			1	2	3	4	5
Projected	-	20	19	18	11	35	9	79	74	88	94	89	67	79	76	91	79	86	26	0

#2

20yr R/L **SCARY Health rating**

Event	Season	HT	WT		R	G	AA	AS		DR	Hlt	Spd
Projected	-	6-0	175	87	91	83	85	88	21	84	46	65	72	52	97

Batting & Pitching Ratings

Event	Season	Con	Pow	vsL	vsR	Eye	BR
Projected	-	77	73	81	74	64	90	67	48

#3

21yr L/L
General & Fielding Ratings

Event	Season	HT	WT		R	G	AA	AS		Dur	Hlt	Spd
Projected	-	6-1	208	88	66	62	77	79	12	100	100	73	95	80	81

Batting & Pitching Ratings

Event	Season
Projected	-	48	85	81	94	75	29	28	72

#4

18yr S/R
General & Fielding Ratings

Event	Season	HT	WT		R	G	AA	AS		Dur	Hlt	Spd
Projected	-	6-0	199	87	82	97	48	75	0	86	92	84	2	29	88

Batting & Pitching Ratings

Event	Season	Con	Pow	vsL	vsR	Eye	BR
Projected	-	62	99	37	66	86	64	66	54

#5

18yr S/R

Event	Season	HT	WT		R	G	AA	AS		Dur	Hlt	Spd
Projected	-	5-11	179	85	88	93	94	81	0	84	100	75	78	61	98

Batting & Pitching Ratings

Event	Season		Pow		vsR	Eye	Br
Projected	-	75	63	70	71	60	73	36	53

I have 16 scouting in both HS and Col

#2 pick in draft

I'm thinking 1,4, 2, 3, 5...

I honestly like 5. Above average in everything. Seems pretty safe, switch hitting shortstop.

#1 - Vs/R is projected 67 and projections are usually high so will probably be low 60's. I don't like that.
#2 - Like you said scary health.
#3- Don't like low contact hitters. And being a lefty with that range should only be LF, RF, or 1B
#4 - Seems like he will be pretty bad against lefties. So I don't like that with a top 2 pick.

So I like 5 unless you want to gamble with 2. Or desperately need SP

1) Health doesn't scare me hardly at all in position players.
2) Does #2 really bat R, throw L? That's really rare in HBD, and he's less valuable in CF than at SS.
3) 4 is good but not like 1, 2, 5; 3 doesn't belong in this discussion.

1, 2, 5, 4, 3; if 2 throws right I'd move him up to about even with 1.

He does throw right and bats left.. I skimp in medical these days so the low hlth could kill me..