Sorry for another "who would you draft", but seriously debating most of these as I have the second pick in the upcoming draft. I have 20M in College and 14M in High School - not sure if I should stick to the 20M scouting or if 14M is good enough to take a chance on a HS bat/arm (#3 or #9). Also, not sure if taking an RP (#4) below is a waste as the #2 pick overall.

Thanks for any advice given.

Player	Pos	B	T	Age	Ovr	Contact	Pwr	vL	vR	Eye	Run	Bunt	PushPull	Range	Glove	Arm Strg	Accur	PC	Health	Speed	Patience	Temper	Makeup	Dur	Stamina	Control	vLHB	vRHB	Velo	GB	1st	2nd	3rd	4th	5th
1	SS	R	R	21	86	73	67	74	80	72	72	66	62	78	91	84	86	3	69	60	80	92	93	86	18	22	0	0	22	33	74	0	0	0	0
2	RF	R	R	22	85	100	72	75	66	69	62	25	53	64	52	66	69	4	100	66	74	46	81	90	30	12	8	16	0	44	53	0	0	0	0
3	SS	R	R	18	87	96	61	77	56	84	85	13	39	83	82	81	73	0	78	59	81	72	85	90	32	16	0	0	23	39	48	0	0	0	0
4	P	L	L	22	81	10	4	17	19	12	12	84	70	8	31	59	60	16	65	36	81	56	66	64	28	85	100	99	98	85	85	85	0	0	0
5	SS	R	R	21	81	77	63	73	80	67	47	44	69	82	86	85	74	0	38	56	68	49	96	88	28	3	11	13	21	25	82	0	0	0	0
6	P	R	R	20	80	28	2	26	22	29	20	50	56	48	41	37	70	33	80	33	52	42	87	29	73	83	64	85	60	66	90	72	59	0	0
7	P	S	R	19	80	27	0	28	21	31	24	58	81	28	30	41	41	3	68	38	100	61	91	33	73	80	60	73	98	100	88	76	75	45	0
8	LF	R	R	19	80	77	74	86	67	82	62	36	36	61	54	46	54	8	98	100	89	83	72	74	14	10	6	3	18	30	39	0	0	0	0
9	P	S	R	18	83	29	0	25	7	35	32	75	83	16	22	26	62	17	79	53	72	19	57	21	90	80	82	87	42	96	90	78	63	52	0

I'm not in love with any of the hitters. That reliever is really tempting as well. The only thing that worries me is the stamina. I think I'd play it safe I like #9

Toss up between 4 and 9.

I'd go 9,4 if you had $20M in HS. The SP could be a bit better or worse than what you see. I might play it safe with the RP. Elite RP is underrated IMO. You could get 100-120 innings of ridiculously low ERA out of him if you use him right.

#4 is first, for me.

#9 second, but a ways behind.

The bats could be solid, but not the difference makers I'd hope for at #2. What is the BR of #8?

9,7,4

The BR of #8 is 62, so not great

I won't take a 60 inning pitcher this high, and I don't trust your $14M scouting or I'd take #9.

I'd take #1 and his perennial All-Star 3B production. Yes, you'd like him better at about #4-5 than #2, but this draft happens to be deeper than it is top-heavy, so you do what you can.

If #4 hits his ratings, he is closer to a 120-inning pitcher than a 60-inning pitcher (meaning I'd expect him to pretty easily get 100+ IP yearly).

#4 is going to end up in your league's hall of fame if you use him correctly, and #9 is good too, and it sounds like that's the consensus

My only issue with 4 is it seems like stamina is always over projected in scouting. So 28 could easily be closer to 20. That's just my experience. It also could be 30+ too but usually it's projected higher it seems to me.

I would draft a guy that wont sign and try again next season with better scouting..

Posted by willsauve on 4/25/2017 1:36:00 PM (view original):
I would draft a guy that wont sign and try again next season with better scouting..

Didn't know you could get better then 20 million scouting.

I went with the RP and he currently has stamina of 29, just an FYI for Kartchy