I'm having trouble deciding on who to redshirt. Right now I have 5 guards, and 4 PF/C...one of the freshmen guards is starting at SF to fulfill recruiting promises. I'd prefer to redshirt Pinnix to give him more time to increase his Athleticism and Defense in case they have massive growth potential, but he has more of a chance to see the floor if one of my guards gets into foul trouble. Corcoran is less needed on the team this season but I feel like the RS might be wasted on him due to having an average at best ath/spd cap. Here is my team:

https://www.whatifsports.com/hd/TeamProfile/Ratings.aspx?tid=13099

Player 1:
https://www.whatifsports.com/hd/PlayerProfile/Ratings.aspx?tid=13099&pid=4464554

ATHLETICISM	26	GREEN
SPEED	52	BLUE
REBOUNDING	13	RED
DEFENSE	28	GREEN
SHOT BLOCKING	1	YELLOW
LOW-POST	15	BLACK
PERIMETER	69	GREEN
BALL HANDLING	50	YELLOW
PASSING	43	GREEN
WORK ETHIC	36
STAMINA	66	GREEN
DURABILITY	69	GREEN
FT SHOOTING	C-	GREEN

Player 2:
https://www.whatifsports.com/hd/PlayerProfile/Ratings.aspx?tid=0&pid=4464552

ATHLETICISM	44	BLACK
SPEED	35	BLUE
REBOUNDING	37	BLACK
DEFENSE	40	BLUE
SHOT BLOCKING	11	GREEN
LOW-POST	36	GREEN
PERIMETER	29	GREEN
BALL HANDLING	41	GREEN
PASSING	49	BLUE
WORK ETHIC	56
STAMINA	66	BLUE
DURABILITY	51	BLUE
FT SHOOTING	C-	BLACK

With that low WE, Pinnix won't benefit much from a redshirt year. I'd only RS him for class balancing purposes.

player 2 definitely offers more from a potential stand point and that's who I would choose

Corcoran. With that many greens, I think it'll be tough for him to max out without a RS season. And the green LP / PER can sometimes keep going and going and going...