I'm only in two drafts, 01-05 and 36-40.

In 01-05, I was really concerned with the cap, so I focused early on finding value. Like getting guys rated well at a position that is not their primary position such as Papi, Manny, and Brandon Inge. Then at around round 10 I realized I wasn't spending enough money so I started spending money on things I don't normally spend a lot of money on: relief pitchers and back of the rotation starters. So I ended up spending half my money on pitching when I typically spend 40-45% on pitching. It's a very non-toysboys type of team so we'll see what happens.

In 36-40 I knew I couldn't close the gap at the end with expensive relief pitchers, so starting round 9, I picked 7 pitchers in a row, all but one relief pitchers. This era had a scarcity of RP so I knew it was important to get them relatively early. I only have one platoon situation so I got 7 $200kish scrubs which means I have little depth. Plus I'm hoping to run a 3 man rotation on a lowered pitch count so this may not end well. But I do have over 1400 innings in a pitcher's park.

Oh and I had to switch to a cheaper version of a player than I had intended on both teams for more balance.

This was really fun, thanks Schwarze.
4/8/2021 7:03 PM
Overall, I found trying to juggle three drafts and work a little much. A couple of times I was trying to use my phone during a meeting and had to catch myself from drafting Josh Donaldson in my 66-70 league or Jay Bruce in the 36-40 league. Also, it's been a long, long time since I've done a draft league and I forgot how difficult it is when drafting with smart people who like the same players I do.

My 36-40 team had hoped to use 37 Medwick but had to change to 36 Medwick 2/3 of the way through. Also had my catching tandem team planned out and thought they were safe when I saw other catchers go, but then Earl Brucker was taken right before I was going to and that caused much consternation, paper crumpling, and tears. I think I was able to recover but it's not the team I envisioned. And the pitching staff - yeesh, Monte Stratton is my ace. I'm not kidding.

My 66-70 team couldn't hit their way out of a paper bag and so, of course, I ended up putting them in a park with a minus for singles. Lou Brock is fast but somehow has zero range in the outfield. My plan all along was to go with Ron Santo at third (he has a cool name) but due to financial restrictions had to go with Brooks Robinson. I'm cautiously optimistic the pitching staff is OK and hope to win a lot of games 1 to 0 or 0 to -2.

My 2011-15 team is short of innings which worries me and relies on Jay Bruce (again, not kidding) as a key cog in the offence. I can only hope Altuve is allowed to use a buzzer under his jersey. The good news is that I was able to use Kevin Pillar, Aaron Sanchez, Marcus Stroman, and, most importantly, Josh Donaldson from the best team in real life history - the post David Price-Tulo trades 2015 Blue Jays (and yet again, not kidding - they were a magical journey for my boys and I until the inglorious end in KC). I should have called them the bat flippers but at least they're in the Rogers Centre.
Good luck everyone.
4/8/2021 7:53 PM (edited)
League #1
In the 1931-35 draft, I knew getting pitching was critical. Of course, so did everybody else. I had 4th pick and was able to get '31 Lefty Grove. The first 14 picks were all starting pitchers (including a few with 100-150 IPs that can be used in long relief). Because the pitching is so weak, I only spent $45 million on pitching. I did however focus on pitchers who can hit, including Red Lucas (.287) and Schoolboy Rowe (.312). Offensively, I like a balanced lineup, so all eight of my starting batters have salaries between $5.7 and $7.2 million. Didn't waste salary on HRs (only 85 team HRs) but my guys have good averages (.326 as a team) and hit lots of doubles and triples. More importantly, my defensive range is outstanding (A, A+, A+, A-, A- B). Only Earl Webb (w/67 doubles) is a poor fielder. As a result, we are playing in League Park II to depress HRs. To combat hitting fatigue, six of my eight batters are over 700 PA, including three over 760 PA. I didn't plan this, but somehow, I have six guys on my team named Bill or Billy.
.
League #2
I had first pick in the 1961-65 draft. On the surface, it seemed like Sandy Koufax was the obvious choice, but there is a plethora of pitching in this league, (and Koufax is pricey) so I wanted to get a stud hitter instead. I love switch hitters so Mickey Mantle was the choice. I got the other good switch hitter of this era in Pete Rose. Unlike the 31-35 league, I did spend money on HRs, getting Billy Williams, Dick Allen, Joe Torre and Roberto Clemente. Once again, my hitting balance includes eight players between $4.9 and $6.6 million. Because I have three regulars under 600 PA (including '62 Mantle), I did have to spend $1.5M each on two platoon batters (but that also gives me two pinch hitters). I spent $51.7 million on position players. My pitching includes 600+ innings of Drysdale (Rd 2) and Ellsworth (Rd 4). I let everybody else grab all their SPs and got solid value later, with two 170-180 innings guys (Donavan and Downing). I didn't plan this, but I have three Dicks on my team and was very close to taking Dick Hall (the namesake of the infamous Big Dick theme) but he was too expensive. The defense isn't great (average rating C/C but nothing worse than D+). Playing in Crosely Field... the +1 HR helps my HR hitters, the -1 1B helps my pitching, which already suppresses batting average with a cumulative team OAV of .207.
.
League #3
I chose 1996-2000, because I was hoping to get either Maddux, Pedro or Kevin Brown. Of course, I drew fourth pick and all three pitchers were gone. Damn it! I went with the hated Roger Clemens (pick 1.4) to limit HRs, but I really wanted to draft an all-switch-hitting team so I had to grab Chipper Jones early (pick 2.1). This caused me to miss out on Randy Johnson, John Smoltz, Kevin Millwood, etc. Screw it... Lets blow off pitching again. I'm just taking players I like and let the chips fall where they may. Two more favorites, Jorge Posada and Bernie Williams are my next picks (not sure which version of Bernie I was going to use). I did grab the HR-prone Curt Schilling next. But after this pick, just about everybody else had their SPs, so I knew I could wait. Keeping an close eye on $Salary/IP, I grabbed some solid good-value RPs (Lowe, G.White, P.Wilson) over the next few rounds. Normally, I would take Roberto Alomar as my 2B but he was a bit too pricey and Jose Offerman is a perfect leadoff hitter (and also a switch hitter). Should I take a SP yet? Nah. Next on the list, even though probably nobody else will take him... Carl Everett (only 535 PA, but .969 OPS and a switch hitter!). The perfect platoon partner... 162-PA Tony Phillips with his .440 obp. Did I mention that he is a switch hitter? I need to make a decision soon on which Bernie Williams season to take. If I take a cheaper season, I need more PA, thus off-setting the cost savings. Instead I decide on a super-saver switch-hitting shortstop, Walt Weiss (623 pa, .381 obp for $3.8M). This allows me Bernie's $8M season - the most expensive hitter I have on all three teams. The only non-switch hitters in the starting lineup, Jeff Bagwell and Bobby Abreu. I absolutely love this team's hitting. But with Mussina and Nomo (taken in rounds 21-22) at the back end of the rotation, we need to win some high-scoring games. Decided on County Stadium to help the pitching. Spent $52M on hitting and Bernie is the only fielder with a range factor better than C+.
4/8/2021 8:46 PM (edited)
1976-1980
You vets can tell me how I did; I don't have the history to judge.
7 fulltime pos players, one platoon (Gamble/Lacy). all with plenty of PA (5200 for 8 spots). Team OPS hitters-only is 917, with some good basestealers. Bats are heavy 2B and 3B hitters, so Exhibition park with + extra base hits, but minus singles. Worst hitter is 80 Yount. Enough good small-PA bench guys to hit for the pitchers.
3man rotation; RJones and Palmer 76, Caldwell 78, will go about 6 IP most starts. Goose77 is the main pen man. Two others as setup, and then lousy guys for mop up. Pitching staff OAV is .230, WHIP 1.1, 87 HR allowed in 1432 IP.

I spent almost $60mil on bats, and not because the defense is awesome. My guess is I am above avg in scoring but below avg in preventing runs, as my rotation ERAs will likely be above 4 in composite; hopefully not worse than 4.5.
4/8/2021 10:08 PM
Q for all: how many guys did you draft intentionally to have multiple seasons of theirs in play, vs knowing ahead of time what season you would use? And, were there any players who you drafted intending to use a certain season but you swapped as you completed your roster?

I think I had 3 multi-season guys, and only one where I surprised myself by switching (Rod Carew 76 to 77)..
4/11/2021 4:26 PM
For the most part I selected players knowing which specific seasons I would be using. The requirement to have five players from every season limited my ability to freewheel as I was always conscious of where the roster was heading. In the 36-40 draft I did start off with my first two picks of DiMaggio and Medwick and ended up using different seasons that I originally anticipated but other than that i used what I was thinking when I selected my players
4/11/2021 7:05 PM
Here are some salary stats on the rostered players...
4/12/2021 2:17 PM
Season Salary Rank
------------ ---------------------- ------------
1931 89,886,634 8
1932 74,104,684 20
1933 71,257,174 24
1934 87,719,136 9
1935 76,927,795 18
1936 101,929,908 1
1937 73,937,243 22
1938 69,162,285 25
1939 67,434,047 26
1940 85,868,387 12
1941 97,037,057 3
1942 57,378,861 29
1943 79,024,667 16
1944 93,669,264 6
1945 72,775,913 23
1946 97,366,226 2
1947 49,285,187 30
1948 76,576,109 19
1949 94,581,505 5
1950 81,618,833 15
1951 60,306,799 28
1952 86,940,954 10
1953 95,404,336 4
1954 82,902,077 13
1955 74,076,847 21
1956 93,049,656 7
1957 77,642,130 17
1958 81,883,961 14
1959 86,496,017 11
1960 60,506,531 27
4/12/2021 2:17 PM
Season Salary Rank
------------ ---------------------- ------------
1961 73,209,285 21
1962 61,671,439 28
1963 85,930,038 9
1964 101,587,189 2
1965 77,272,126 18
1966 90,279,462 7
1967 76,756,705 19
1968 75,319,525 20
1969 94,561,812 4
1970 62,920,557 27
1971 91,147,872 6
1972 126,444,927 1
1973 50,540,669 29
1974 64,011,621 26
1975 67,662,616 25
1976 82,845,135 13
1977 91,986,054 5
1978 69,257,576 23
1979 70,142,966 22
1980 85,055,135 10
1981 89,392,811 8
1982 48,925,550 30
1983 80,918,067 17
1984 81,113,338 16
1985 98,774,036 3
1986 82,299,871 14
1987 67,852,211 24
1988 84,211,522 11
1989 81,942,687 15
1990 83,489,069 12
4/12/2021 2:18 PM
Season Salary Rank
------------ ---------------------- ------------
1991 81,543,586 16
1992 98,789,804 2
1993 73,377,559 22
1994 69,059,299 23
1995 76,691,835 19
1996 97,156,238 3
1997 83,355,521 13
1998 82,819,234 14
1999 73,985,666 21
2000 62,078,039 26
2001 76,623,907 20
2002 92,226,904 7
2003 85,941,837 12
2004 52,099,145 30
2005 92,879,347 6
2006 68,292,465 24
2007 97,072,730 4
2008 59,848,826 28
2009 86,651,682 11
2010 87,579,549 10
2011 91,691,158 8
2012 54,668,888 29
2013 88,379,779 9
2014 65,456,410 25
2015 99,726,229 1
2016 61,972,340 27
2017 79,572,518 18
2018 80,771,424 17
2019 82,554,728 15
2020 94,961,797 5
4/12/2021 2:18 PM

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2025 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.