League #1
In the 1931-35 draft, I knew getting pitching was critical. Of course, so did everybody else. I had 4th pick and was able to get '31 Lefty Grove. The first 14 picks were all starting pitchers (including a few with 100-150 IPs that can be used in long relief). Because the pitching is so weak, I only spent $45 million on pitching. I did however focus on pitchers who can hit, including Red Lucas (.287) and Schoolboy Rowe (.312). Offensively, I like a balanced lineup, so all eight of my starting batters have salaries between $5.7 and $7.2 million. Didn't waste salary on HRs (only 85 team HRs) but my guys have good averages (.326 as a team) and hit lots of doubles and triples. More importantly, my defensive range is outstanding (A, A+, A+, A-, A- B). Only Earl Webb (w/67 doubles) is a poor fielder. As a result, we are playing in League Park II to depress HRs. To combat hitting fatigue, six of my eight batters are over 700 PA, including three over 760 PA. I didn't plan this, but somehow, I have six guys on my team named Bill or Billy.
.
League #2
I had first pick in the 1961-65 draft. On the surface, it seemed like Sandy Koufax was the obvious choice, but there is a plethora of pitching in this league, (and Koufax is pricey) so I wanted to get a stud hitter instead. I love switch hitters so Mickey Mantle was the choice. I got the other good switch hitter of this era in Pete Rose. Unlike the 31-35 league, I did spend money on HRs, getting Billy Williams, Dick Allen, Joe Torre and Roberto Clemente. Once again, my hitting balance includes eight players between $4.9 and $6.6 million. Because I have three regulars under 600 PA (including '62 Mantle), I did have to spend $1.5M each on two platoon batters (but that also gives me two pinch hitters). I spent $51.7 million on position players. My pitching includes 600+ innings of Drysdale (Rd 2) and Ellsworth (Rd 4). I let everybody else grab all their SPs and got solid value later, with two 170-180 innings guys (Donavan and Downing). I didn't plan this, but I have three Dicks on my team and was very close to taking Dick Hall (the namesake of the infamous Big Dick theme) but he was too expensive. The defense isn't great (average rating C/C but nothing worse than D+). Playing in Crosely Field... the +1 HR helps my HR hitters, the -1 1B helps my pitching, which already suppresses batting average with a cumulative team OAV of .207.
.
League #3
I chose 1996-2000, because I was hoping to get either Maddux, Pedro or Kevin Brown. Of course, I drew fourth pick and all three pitchers were gone. Damn it! I went with the hated Roger Clemens (pick 1.4) to limit HRs, but I really wanted to draft an all-switch-hitting team so I had to grab Chipper Jones early (pick 2.1). This caused me to miss out on Randy Johnson, John Smoltz, Kevin Millwood, etc. Screw it... Lets blow off pitching again. I'm just taking players I like and let the chips fall where they may. Two more favorites, Jorge Posada and Bernie Williams are my next picks (not sure which version of Bernie I was going to use). I did grab the HR-prone Curt Schilling next. But after this pick, just about everybody else had their SPs, so I knew I could wait. Keeping an close eye on $Salary/IP, I grabbed some solid good-value RPs (Lowe, G.White, P.Wilson) over the next few rounds. Normally, I would take Roberto Alomar as my 2B but he was a bit too pricey and Jose Offerman is a perfect leadoff hitter (and also a switch hitter). Should I take a SP yet? Nah. Next on the list, even though probably nobody else will take him... Carl Everett (only 535 PA, but .969 OPS and a switch hitter!). The perfect platoon partner... 162-PA Tony Phillips with his .440 obp. Did I mention that he is a switch hitter? I need to make a decision soon on which Bernie Williams season to take. If I take a cheaper season, I need more PA, thus off-setting the cost savings. Instead I decide on a super-saver switch-hitting shortstop, Walt Weiss (623 pa, .381 obp for $3.8M). This allows me Bernie's $8M season - the most expensive hitter I have on all three teams. The only non-switch hitters in the starting lineup, Jeff Bagwell and Bobby Abreu. I absolutely love this team's hitting. But with Mussina and Nomo (taken in rounds 21-22) at the back end of the rotation, we need to win some high-scoring games. Decided on County Stadium to help the pitching. Spent $52M on hitting and Bernie is the only fielder with a range factor better than C+.
4/8/2021 8:46 PM (edited)