I tried for several years to achieve this with Clarkson and Morris to no avail, reaching the upper 800 and low 900 innings a few times and maxing out at 117 games and 986 IP. Now that I have a better grasp of the appearance fatigue mechanics, I know why I haven't been able to achieve those figure, but even though it wasn't done the same way, I finally achieved both with probably the worst pitching performance I've ever seen:
Denny Stark put up 1,095 IP over 162 games. Finished with a 2-64 record, .511 OAV, 4.31 WHIP, and 23.88 ERA. He allowed 431 HR, and had an incredible 2 strikeouts to 1,526 BB.
Incredibly, on defense, he recorded 24 + plays, despite playing virtually the entire season at 0%, which in his 1,095 IP on defense, was better than all but 1 other player in the league (2017 Lorenzo Cain, who had 38 + plays in 1,427 defensive innings) that wasn't on Stark's team. His FLD% suffered, but it certainly made me wonder about the impact of fatigue on + plays. Given his own pitching metrics, he certainly gave himself more chances than otherwise, but how much did that offset the fatigue effect? Chapman & Lemon didn't recorded but a handful more + plays than the most I've seen them record before... hard to say for sure, but certainly fascinating.