Re-Destribution Draft, V2 1998-2021 Topic

DRAFTS ARE FUN! This league will conduct a 24-person draft, where there are 24 positional "buckets", where each person will pick one player from each bucket.

Upon entry into this league, each owner will select a unique franchise from the 30 franchises listed below. The franchise you select will not directly impact the strength of your roster so there is no advantage to picking early or selecting a "better" franchise. You are simply determining which players are being added to the draft pool. The owner of each franchise will submit (in a site-mail to me) a 24-man roster (13 hitters and 11 pitchers). You should try to use the franchise's best players. There is no salary cap.

We are using years 1998-2021.

Main Roster Build Rules
1. You must select 13 hitters and 11 pitchers. Salary does not matter. The players should be usable and not scrubs.
2. You will select one full-time 1B, 2B, 3B, SS and 3 full-time OFs, each of these players must have 550+ PA/162.
3. You will select one "starting" catcher who should have at least 400 PA/162.
4. You will select one "backup" catcher who should have between 100-300 PA/162.
5. Your other four part-time hitters (each with <=400 PA/162) should include any positions, include pinch hitters or defensive replacements (i.e., useful in some way).
6. You will select five starting pitchers (must be designated as SP) that total at least 1000 IP/162. The fewest IP/162 for any individual SP is 150. There is no lefty/right requirement.
7. You will select six "other" pitchers (SP or RP) with < 150 innings. The total cumulative IP of these six pitchers >= 400 IP/162.

Bonus Players
After you determine your 24 man roster, please add two bonus players (one hitter & one pitcher). The bonus round hitter should either be a decent starting player or a really really strong bench player (somebody who may be desirable in the Round 25 draft). Example: Say you have two really good 2B and have to pick one for your 24-man roster. The other 2B could be your bonus hitter. There is no PA requirement. This could be where you include a player with 401-550 PA if there was a stud that you couldn't legally fit into the 24-man roster. (Clone not allowed for bonus hitter).

The bonus round pitcher can be a starting pitcher or a reliever and there is no inning requirement. Because you should be selecting the best pitchers to be part of your 24-man lineup, I will allow a clone (of one of your other 11 pitchers) to be selected here.

The Draft
Once all the rosters are submitted to me, I will post all 24 player buckets. Each bucket will have 30 players in it, one from each team.

Now, here's the key to drafting --> You cannot roster more than ONE PLAYER FROM EACH FRANCHISE. So if you draft Nomar Garciaparra (Boston) from the SS bucket, then you can't draft Red Sox Pedro. As the draft progresses, there will be opportunities to skip ahead since those picking in front of you won't be able to draft from certain buckets and/or can't draft from certain franchises. Since there are 30 franchises and 24 drafting rounds, you will have 6 franchises un-represented.

The first round of the draft will be determined randomly, but each successive round will be based on lowest cumulative salary. Also, the division alignment will be based on final team salary (the four most expensive rosters will be in the NL East).

What about the 25th Player?
The 25th round will contain all 60 bonus players (pitchers and hitters). The draft order is the same as the other rounds (lowest cumulative salary drafts first). Each owner will only be able to draft from the 6 franchises they did not select during the 24-round draft. So you won't be able to draft 2016 Kershaw (he is a bonus pitcher) if you already used your Dodgers pick. At the end of this round, every owner should have 25 different franchises represented on their roster.

Getting Stuck
In version 1, we had only 24 franchises represented so it was common for somebody to get stuck and not be able to legally draft a player from a specific bucket. This round we have 30 franchises in each bucket so it will be a lot harder to get stuck (but not impossible). If somehow you still end up getting stuck and have to pick a default player, you will simply choose any <300K player from a franchise you didn't draft. The player must be from a position you defaulted at. You will also be penalized $100M (per defaulted player) in salary for purposes of the round 25 draft order and division alignment. If you get stuck in round 25, then you the same rules applies - you must take a <300K player from one of the franchises you don't have represented on your roster.

Other Details
Eligible Seasons: 1998-2021
Salary Cap: None
DH: No
WW: No
AAA: No
Injuries: No
Trades: No
Clones: Yes (during the draft, it's allowed to draft clones)
Ballpark: Must use a park that one of your drafted players played in during that season
Alignment: Based on final team salary (Top 4 salaries in NL East)

When sending me your roster via site-mail, it's easiest to simply copy/paste the entire roster from the Team Center (with no editing needed). List the bonus players last in each section, so It's easy for me to identify.
5/9/2022 4:51 PM (edited)
Franchise List

Angels - schwarze
Astros - thejuice6
Athletics - mllama54
Blue Jays - ronthegenius
Braves - alice
Brewers - nocomm999
Cardinals - Chisock
Cubs - NebHusker
Diamondbacks - bheid408
Dodgers - calhoop
Giants - dilligafdbp
Indians - rmarksduke
Mariners - beauchamp
Marlins - barracuda3
Mets - schwarze
Nationals - pedrocerrano
Orioles - schwarze
Padres - mpitt76
Phillies - redcped
Pirates - schwarze
Rangers - schwarze
Rays - bigsteve12
Reds - njbigwig
Red Sox - midknight
Rockies - fatguyrd
Royals - schwarze
Tigers - ff09
Twins - footballmm11
White Sox - schwarze
Yankees - zephyr1949
5/10/2022 9:38 AM (edited)
Sign-Up List (and franchise selection order)

1. calhoop - Los Angeles Dodgers
2. ronthegenius. - Toronto Blue Jays
3. bigsteve12 - Tampa Bay Rays
4. mllama54 - Oakland Athletics
5. fatguyrd- Colorado Rockies
6. dilligafdbp San Francisco Giants
7. redcped - Philadelphia Phillies
8. njbigwig - Cincinnati Reds
9. NebHusker - Chicago Cubs
10. midknight - Boston Red Sox
11. pedrocerrano - Montreal Expos/Washington Nationals
12. thejuice6 - Houston Astros
13. ff09 - Detroit Tigers
14. zephyr1949 - New York Yankees
15. nocomm999 - Milwaukee Brewers
16. footballmm11 - Minnesota Twins
17. Chisock - St. Louis Cardinals
18. mpitt76 - San Diego Padres
19. bheid408 - Arizona Diamondbacks
20. alice - Atlanta Braves
21. beauchamp - Seattle Mariners
22. rmarksduke - Cleveland Indiana
23. barracuda3 - Florida/Miami Marlins
24. schwarze (will select the rosters for the franchises remaining)

Site-mail list:
calhoop; ronthegenius; bigsteve12; mllama54; fatguyrd; dilligafdbp; redcped; njbigwig; NebHusker; midknight; pedrocerrano; thejuice6; ff09; zephyr1949; nocomm999; footballmm11; Chisock; mpitt76; bheid408; schwarze; alice; beauchamp; rmarksduke; barracuda3
5/10/2022 8:40 AM (edited)
These drafts are fast-paced drafts and require you to check in frequently. Please do not sign up if you are unable or unwilling to check site-mail multiple times throughout the day (proxies are fine too). We average almost 2 picks per person per day.
5/9/2022 10:32 AM
I will take the Atlanta Braves please!
5/9/2022 10:43 AM
I'll take a spot.
5/9/2022 1:36 PM
I'll take a spot too.
5/9/2022 2:24 PM (edited)
What about the 25th Player?
The 25th round will contain all 60 bonus players (pitchers and hitters). The draft order is the same as the other rounds (lowest cumulative salary drafts first). Each owner will only be able to draft from the 6 franchises they did not select during the 24-round draft. So you won't be able to draft 2016 Kershaw if you already used your Dodgers pick. At the end of this round, every owner should have 25 different franchises represented on their roster.

In other words, Kershaw could never appear more than twice in the league and only once on your roster because he has only played on the Dodgers. But Greinke could theoretically appear ten times in the league and five times as a clone on your team because he played for the Royals, Brewers, Dodgers, Diamondbacks, and Astros. In Kershaws case Calhoop could nominate him twice once as a SP and once as his bonus pitcher but I could only draft one Dodger version of him.

But in Greinke’s case each user of the Royals, Dodgers, Diamondbacks, Brewers, and Astros could nominate him as SP and a bonus pitcher which would hypothetically put 10 versions of him to be drafted. Of which I could draft one from each franchise. Did I get it right?
5/9/2022 3:55 PM (edited)
You are correct. Clones are allowed. Drafting more than one player per franchise is not allowed.

Keep in mind that you cannot draft two versions of the same player *and same year*, even if on two different franchises. The sim won't allow that.

By the way, great example using Greinke. I may try to build a starting pitching staff of all the Greinkes.
5/9/2022 4:18 PM (edited)
I know beauchamp picks before me, so I'll take
1) Indians
2) White Sox (This forum really should not put the red, misspelled, squiggly line under the word "Sox". The word should be added the the spell check dictionary by now)
5/10/2022 9:48 PM (edited)
Are there writeups? I hope there are writeups. I'd like in with the Marlins, please.
5/10/2022 5:34 AM
Quick update. I have all the rosters and am checking to see if any changes are necessary. I think we're close to having the final set. Based on what I currently have, here are some interesting stats...
.
Bucket Players Avg Salary Avg PA/IP
C 30 5,158,616 572
1B 30 7,313,450 686
2B 30 6,552,042 668
3B 30 6,853,277 666
SS 30 6,601,936 657
OF1 30 7,747,695 700
OF2 30 6,625,482 672
OF3 30 6,492,533 622
C2 30 2,042,020 215
Bench1 30 2,878,898 353
Bench2 30 2,493,885 264
Bench3 30 1,990,845 198
Bench4 30 1,424,127 135
SP1 30 7,755,665 236
SP2 30 7,353,548 222
SP3 30 6,996,812 211
SP4 30 6,756,819 201
SP5 30 6,260,485 185
RP1 30 4,150,468 110
RP2 30 3,592,306 83
RP3 30 3,413,247 74
RP4 30 2,977,065 67
RP5 30 3,029,233 60
RP6 30 2,463,843 51
BonusH 30 6,335,733 618
BonusP 30 4,839,484 121
.
Excluding the Bonus Round, the average team salary is $118.9 million. (Probably a bit less since 6 players from each bucket won't be drafted, and it's likely they will be the lower-salaried players).

(If anybody wants me to send the current player list in a site-mail, let me know).
5/11/2022 3:46 PM (edited)
Posted by barracuda3 on 5/10/2022 5:34:00 AM (view original):
Are there writeups? I hope there are writeups. I'd like in with the Marlins, please.
Not barracuda-worthy, but yes, there’s write-ups
https://www.whatifsports.com/forums/Posts.aspx?topicID=531856&page=54&TopicsPage=0
5/11/2022 6:45 PM
Do I need to pick 1 and only 1 player from each bucket?
5/15/2022 11:23 PM
Posted by rmarksduke on 5/15/2022 11:23:00 PM (view original):
Do I need to pick 1 and only 1 player from each bucket?
Pretty sure the answer is yes. Which is all part of the challenge.

From the theme description above:
" DRAFTS ARE FUN! This league will conduct a 24-person draft, where there are 24 positional "buckets", where each person will pick one player from each bucket. "
5/16/2022 12:17 AM (edited)
Re-Destribution Draft, V2 1998-2021 Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2025 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.