140M Draft Thread Topic

$140 Million - Quick Drafts (Post-Deadball, Pre-Steroid Era Edition)

The Setup:
There will be six independent 4-person drafts.The top six finishers from round 1 will be captains who make the initial choices. Starting with the 1st place owner, they will pick one of the original 16 franchises. Same for #2, #3, #4, #5 and #6. These six will each represent a different division. They will draft 4th in each division draft.

The next six owners choose a different original 16 franchise and will be slotted into the division (snake draft style) with one of the top six owners (owners 6 & 7 together, owners 1 & 12 together). They will draft 3rd in each division draft.

The third six (13-18) choose an expansion franchise and which group they join. They will draft 2nd in each division draft.
The final six (19-24) choose their group (in which they’ll have 1st pick) and assign the group in the division alignment.

The Drafts:

The drafts will be 20 rounds:
Rounds 1-16, 1 player (16)
Rounds 17-18, 2 players (4)
Rounds 19-20, 3 players (6)
That’s 26 picks, because you would also draft a ballpark (must be in use from one of your franchises in these years)

The division drafts will be serpentine (1-4, 4-1, 1-4). Players are exclusive within each division. When a player is drafted, he is off the board for that draft (the person drafting does not have to specify which season he is using). You must use a season he played for one of your franchises.

(To be clear, let’s say one division includes the Reds. You can draft any Reds season for Frank Robinson. If another division has the Orioles, someone can draft any FRob Orioles season in that draft. But there’s no crossover.)

Seasons: 1920-1990

DH: Yes

Clones: No

Ballpark: Draft any stadium any of your franchises used in the era

Alignment: as determined above

Combined seasons: You can use partial or combined seasons

300K exceptions: No

Team name: No restrictions

EDIT:
Question:

In the unlikely event that franchises only have a single stadium in the 1920-1990 (ex. Fenway, Wrigley, Astrodome) could you also add WIS park as an available option?

Answer:
Yes: If there are fewer than 4 stadiums available, then WhatifSports Park will be the fourth stadium.

9/10/2025 1:33 PM (edited)
Owner AL East___ NL West___ AL Central__ NL East___ NL Central__ AL West___
1 _JJP_ Yankees . . . . .
2 hebdomad . Dodgers . . . .
3 redcped . . Cardinals . . .
4 discodemo . . . Giants . .
5 jfranco77 . . . . Red Sox .
6 ozomatli . . . . . Indians
7 emanes10 . . . . . Reds
8 justinlee_24 . . . . Athletics .
9 mjkrunner . . . White Sox . .
10 cubbies84 . . Browns/Orioles . . .
11 ledfoot . Tigers . . . .
12 Bansberg Cubs . . . . .
13 d_rock97 . . . . . Astros
14 mllama54 . . . Mets . .
15 schwarze . . Royals . . .
16 Jtpsops . Brewers . . . .
17 duhbigcat . . . . Expos .
18 redsfive Padres . . . . .
19 jbohrman . . . . . AL West
20 DarthDurron . . . NL East . .
21 barracuda3 AL East . . . . .
22 buddhagamer . . AL Central . . .
23 MJDSupporter . NL West . . . .
24 newarkwilder . . . . NL Central .
9/15/2025 1:00 PM (edited)
Draft Order
.
Owner
1 _JJP_
2 hebdomad
3 redcped
4 discodemo
5 jfranco77
6 ozomatli
7 emanes10
8 justinlee_24
9 mjkrunner
10 cubbies84
11 ledfoot
12 Bansberg
13 d_rock97
14 mllama54
15 schwarze
16 Jtpsops
17 duhbigcat
18 redsfive
19 jbohrman
20 DarthDurron
21 barracuda3
22 buddhagamer
23 MJDSupporter
24 newarkwilder
9/10/2025 12:47 PM
I am assuming we can start this draft anytime, right?
9/10/2025 4:22 PM
I'm anxiously awaiting JJP's pick knowing I'm tied to it
9/10/2025 4:58 PM
Also, just to get this question out of the way, is there a minimum number of players from each of the three Franchises per division that have to be drafted? Or in theory could your team be heavily skewed towards one of the selected franchises?
9/10/2025 5:19 PM
ronthegenius, redcped and I discussed this and we decided to keep it simple. No minimum number of players per franchise required.
9/10/2025 5:36 PM
Posted by Bansberg on 9/10/2025 4:58:00 PM (view original):
I'm anxiously awaiting JJP's pick knowing I'm tied to it
Just so you're not waiting in suspense, I likely won't be picking until early next week.
9/10/2025 5:50 PM
I sincerely hope we’re not waiting another week just for this to start.
9/10/2025 5:58 PM
Yankees
9/11/2025 8:40 PM
To clear up any question in advance:

Even if a player appeared for multiple franchises within a division group, only one version can be drafted.
9/11/2025 9:11 PM
Dodgers
9/11/2025 9:11 PM
Cardinals
9/11/2025 9:28 PM
GIANTS
9/12/2025 8:45 AM
I was hoping disco might get distracted by a shiny group of hitters or pitchers since there's a very very clear top 3, and then I like the Giants 4th by a lot.

At any rate I'm going to pick the hated Boston Red Sox and hope that they pair well with the other teams we end up with in my division.
9/12/2025 10:08 AM
12345 Next ▸
140M Draft Thread Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2025 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.