Players Selected
.
Aurilia, Rich 2001 Hubbell, Carl 1933 Mays, Willie 1958
Bancroft, Dave 1921 Hubbell, Carl 1934 Mays, Willie 1962
Bancroft, Dave 1922 Hubbell, Carl 1936 McCovey, Willie 1969
Bonds, Barry 1993 Kent, Jeff 2000 McGinnity, Joe 1904
Bonds, Barry 1996 Lincecum, Tim 2009 Nehf, Art 1919 partial
Bonds, Barry 2001 Marichal, Juan 1965 Ott, Mel 1938
Bonds, Barry 2002 Marichal, Juan 1966 Posey, Buster 2012
Bonds, Barry 2003 Marichal, Juan 1969 Sandoval, Pablo 2009
Bonds, Barry 2004 Mathewson, Christy 1905 Schmidt, Jason 2003
Crawford, Brandon 2021 Mathewson, Christy 1907 Schupp, Ferdie 1916
Frisch, Frankie 1921 Mathewson, Christy 1908 Terry, Bill 1930
Frisch, Frankie 1923 Mathewson, Christy 1909 Tesreau, Jeff 1915
Frisch, Frankie 1924 Mays, Willie 1954 Toney, Fred 1918 partial
Hearn, Jim 1950 Mays, Willie 1955
Hornsby, Rogers 1927 Mays, Willie 1957
1/21/2026 8:46 PM (edited)
Draft Results
.
ROUND 1
Owner________ Player________ Salary_______ New Salary____
nocomm999 Mathewson, Christy 1909 15,481,095 15,481,095
calhoop Hornsby, Rogers 1927 10,148,698 10,148,698
footballmm11 Bonds, Barry 2004 22,107,994 22,107,994
emanes10 Mathewson, Christy 1908 17,670,630 17,670,630
schwarze Hubbell, Carl 1933 12,114,190 12,114,190
ff09 Mathewson, Christy 1905 14,341,519 14,341,519
DarthDurron Marichal, Juan 1966 12,390,166 12,390,166
njbigwig Hubbell, Carl 1936 10,768,210 10,768,210
chewy3344 Bonds, Barry 2002 15,795,171 15,795,171
mllama54 Bonds, Barry 2001 17,601,504 17,601,504
pedrocerrano Terry, Bill 1930 9,792,769 9,792,769
ronthegenius Frisch, Frankie 1921 7,699,530 7,699,530
thejuice6 Ott, Mel 1938 9,243,589 9,243,589
Jtpsops Hearn, Jim 1950 5,751,395 5,751,395
3dayrotation Crawford, Brandon 2021 5,949,432 5,949,432
bigsteve12 Bancroft, Dave 1921 7,449,467 7,449,467
.
ROUND 2
Owner________ Player________ Salary_______ New Salary____
Jtpsops Bonds, Barry 2003 11,347,263 17,098,658
3dayrotation Frisch, Frankie 1923 7,918,856 13,868,288
bigsteve12 Frisch, Frankie 1924 8,043,086 15,492,553
ronthegenius Bonds, Barry 1993 10,094,180 17,793,710
thejuice6 Nehf, Art 1919 partial 6,065,355 15,308,944
pedrocerrano Mays, Willie 1954 11,267,636 21,060,405
calhoop Schupp, Ferdie 1916 8,251,387 18,400,085
njbigwig Schmidt, Jason 2003 8,643,694 19,411,904
schwarze Toney, Fred 1918 partial 7,383,267 19,497,457
DarthDurron McGinnity, Joe 1904 14,018,414 26,408,580
ff09 Posey, Buster 2012 7,201,123 21,542,642
nocomm999 Marichal, Juan 1965 10,387,386 25,868,481
chewy3344 Kent, Jeff 2000 7,728,473 23,523,644
mllama54 Mathewson, Christy 1907 11,673,459 29,274,963
emanes10 McCovey, Willie 1969 9,519,439 27,190,069
footballmm11 Marichal, Juan 1969 10,273,331 32,381,325
1/21/2026 3:44 PM (edited)
ROUND 1
Owner________
1 nocomm999
2 calhoop
3 footballmm11
4 emanes10
5 schwarze
6 ff09
7 DarthDurron
8 njbigwig
9 chewy3344
10 mllama54
11 pedrocerrano
12 ronthegenius
13 thejuice6
14 Jtpsops
15 3dayrotation
16 bigsteve12
1/19/2026 10:34 PM
1909 Christy Mathewson - $15,481,095
1/20/2026 11:41 AM
1927 Rogers Hornsby $10,148,698
1/20/2026 11:58 AM
See you in a week for my next pick...

2004 Barry Bonds $22,107,994
1/20/2026 1:29 PM
1908 Christy Mathewson - $17,670,630
1/20/2026 1:56 PM
There is a certain starting pitcher who is currently 5-12 with a 7.94 ERA for me in round 3 of the draft tournament that is available in this draft and who will certainly get selected in round 1. It will NOT be me who selects him. In fact, I doubt that I will ever use this guy again.

Instead, I will take... 1933 Carl Hubbell, $12,114,190
1/20/2026 2:33 PM
well, it's probably this guy. but hopefully he can only get better.
$14,341,519 1905 Mathewson
1/20/2026 3:00 PM
This guy has done well for me for 3 rounds of the Eras draft tournament. So, of course, he'll probably bomb out in the Franchise draft tournament.

1966 Juan Marichal - $12,390,166
1/20/2026 3:10 PM
1936 Carl Hubbell $10,768,210
1/20/2026 3:51 PM
Posted by ff09 on 1/20/2026 3:00:00 PM (view original):
well, it's probably this guy. but hopefully he can only get better.
$14,341,519 1905 Mathewson
Yep, you are correct. He's now a $14 million mop-up pitcher.

This is the team that won 110 games in round 1 (outscoring it's opponents by 350 runs).

In round 2, I replaced a 200K player with '02 Bill Bernhard in the mini-draft, and won only 82 games in round 2, But we were 11-22 in 1-run games and were +78 in run differential, so bad luck.

In round 3, I replaced another 200K player with '05 Mathewson in the mini-draft, and the team is now in last place with a 57-65 record (-55 run differential).

So '05 Mathewson is forever on my sh*t list.
1/20/2026 4:50 PM
2002 Barry Bonds 15,795,171
1/20/2026 5:40 PM
2001 Barry Bonds $17,601,504
1/20/2026 6:34 PM
1930 Bill Terry - $9,792,769
1/20/2026 7:29 PM
12345 Next ▸

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2026 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.